Subsidy control cases coming into land
The Welsh Government has published a statement advising that on 25 June, it had received notice that the decision to award a £205m subsidy to Cardiff Airport to improve facilities would be challenged by Bristol Airport.
This is the first time an acknowledged subsidy has been challenged in the Competition Appeals Tribunal (CAT) and the fourth challenge launched under the Subsidy Control Act 2022.
Previous challenges to the Subsidy Control Act 2022
The previous challenges, relating to the question of whether or not a subsidy has actually been granted, include:
- In Durham, a competitor of the council’s commercial waste collection business argued that the Council was using its statutory waste collection service to subsidise commercial activity.
- In Weis, a property developer argued that the council had made loans which amounted to subsidies without considering its obligations under the Act. This case is still awaiting judgment.
- The recently issued New Lottery Company v The Gambling Commission involves a decision of the Commission to grant an alleged subsidy to Camelot to contribute to marketing spend promoting the business of the National Lottery.
Because the Bristol Airport case relates to an acknowledged subsidy, the CAT will need to consider the decision made by the Welsh Government as to the subsidy’s compliance with the subsidy principles set out within the Act.
What could this mean for the future of subsidy control challenges?
It will be interesting to see if the CAT adopts the relatively 'hands off' approach used by the court in cases, such as British Gas and E.On v Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, which challenged the government’s subsidisation of energy supplier Bulb.
Additionally, it's important to note what level of scrutiny the CAT will apply to decisions made by public authorities. This is particularly relevant in this case, as the Competition and Markets Authority has already reviewed the assessment conducted by the Welsh Government.
In any event, it’s clear that after a very slow start, competitors are now more prepared to bring challenges on subsidy control grounds, and we expect the judgments in these cases to provide much needed clarity for public authorities making these assessments.
Contact
Angelica Hymers
Principal Associate
angelica.hymers@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)115 976 6092
Discover more
Related expertise
You may be interested in
Legal Update
Subsidy control cases coming into land
Legal Update
Government publishes response to consultation on Subsidy Control Regime
Legal Update
Refining the UK subsidy control regime consultation
Legal Update
The housing benefit subsidy deficit: Strategies for funding temporary accommodation
Published Article
The legal and planning hurdles that must be overcome to get Great British Energy generating
Legal Update
Update on local authority owned companies: Part 1 subsidy control
Legal Update
Does the subsidy control regime already need changing for the government to kickstart economic growth?
Legal Update
The transparency regime under the Subsidy Control Act - how it could be improved
Legal Update
Subsidy control guidance update - welcome guidance on 'small subsidies' introduced
Legal Update
Subsidy control: Guide to streamlined routes for universities
Legal Update
Subsidy control - lessons learned in the first year
Legal Update
Review of a subsidy control decision: The Durham Company Ltd v Durham County Council, 27 July 2023
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advising the Welsh Government on the delivery of significant number of renewable energy projects
Legal Update
Subsidy control lessons to be learnt from Bulb
Legal Update - Public matters newsletter
Public matters - February 2023
Legal Update
Government introduces first Streamlined Subsidy Schemes under new regime
Legal Update - Public matters newsletter
Public matters - January 2023
On-Demand
The Subsidy Control Act 2022. Putting the new regime into practice
Legal Update
Government provides guidance on new Subsidy Control Database and the calculation of their value
Legal Update
The impact of the new Subsidy Control regime on public regeneration projects
Legal Update
Subsidy Control Act 2022: economic queries
In July, the long-awaited statutory guidance on the Subsidy Control Act 2022 (Act) was published in draft form (Draft Guidance). A consultation on the draft guidance has recently ended and the results have not yet been published – it may therefore change before the final version is published.
Legal Update
Economic activity for the purposes of the Subsidy Control Act 2022
When carrying out a mix of activities it can be less clear if it is 'economic'. We look at the impact on local authorities & charities.
Opinion
The UK’s first domestic subsidy control case
We waited more than a year for it, but the wait is over – we finally have a domestic case on the new subsidy control regime.
On-Demand
Subsidy control webinar - 30 March 2022
In this on-demand session, Alex Kynoch and Angelica Hymers explore the practicalities of complying with the new Subsidy Control Bill, and the impact of illustrative guidance and policy statements recently published by the Government.
Published Article
The Subsidy Control Bill – Illustrative Guidance and Regulations – legal certainty vs flexibility
It has been a turbulent couple of years for those involved in subsidy control, and 2022 will be equally challenging. The Subsidy Control Bill (Bill) will take effect in 2022.
Legal Update
Subsidy control regime: new Bill working its way through Parliament
2022 is the year in which the UK’s new post-Brexit subsidy control regime will take effect. The new Subsidy Control Bill will form the backbone of the UK’s new subsidy control regime. The new Bill will replace the EU’s state aid rules, which applied until the end of the Brexit transition period.
Legal Update
New Year, New Subsidy Control Regime Part 2: Schemes, enforcement and transparency under the Subsidy Control Bill
In the first part of this article, we discussed the application of the Subsidy Control Principles. In part 2, we look at how Streamlined Subsidy Schemes will be used to grant certain subsidies more quickly, and at the enforcement and transparency provisions of the Bill.
Legal Update
New Year, New Subsidy Control Regime Part 1: The principles, restrictions and exemptions under the Subsidy Control Bill
The repeal of the State aid rules and their replacement by the regime stemming from the UK-EU Trade and Co-operation Agreement (TCA) in 2021 meant that practitioners and public bodies had to acclimatise to a new, more flexible but less certain approach.
Press Release
Browne Jacobson’s government & infrastructure lawyers advise on first South West based green hydrogen production project
Browne Jacobson’s specialist government and infrastructure team have advised Canford Renewable Energy Ltd on the delivery of its Dorset Green H2 facility.
Published Article
Subsidy control after Brexit - a practitioner's perspective
Back in late 2020, we waited expectantly for news of what the rules on state aid were going to be when the Brexit transition period ended on 31 December.
Legal Update
Consultation on new UK subsidy control regime
It is vitally important that public bodies make use of this opportunity to have their views heard and to shape the future of the new subsidy control regime.
Opinion
Consultation launched on the future of subsidy control law
The Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy has just launched its consultation on the future of subsidy control law (previously known as state aid) in the UK.
Legal Update
New year, new-ish state aid rules: the new subsidy control regime
Until a formal subsidy regime is put in place funding bodies must grapple with the complex and challenging exercise of legal obligations from the UK-EU TCA and numerous trade agreements to grant funding.
On-Demand
State aid and subsidy control - post Brexit
Opinion
New Year, new-ish state aid rules
From 1 January 2021 the state aid principles set out in the Trade and Co-Operation Agreement are incorporated into law by the EU (Future Relationship) Act 2020.
Legal Update
State aid - De Minimis Regulation - Article 3 and 6
The case of Istituto nazionale per l’assicurazione contro gli infortuni sul lavoro (INAIL) v Zennaro Giuseppe Legnami Sas di Zennaro Mauro & C concerns the application of the De Minimis Regulation.
Legal Update
Commission decisions reinforce the position on when measures adopted by publicly owned companies will be classed as state resources for the purposes of the state aid rules
Are measures adopted by publicly owned companies state resources for the purposes of state aid rules?
Legal Update
European Commission amends the Temporary Framework and prolongs existing state aid rules
The European Commission has taken this decision due to the effects of the current crisis and after consultation with member states.
On-Demand
COVID-19 for local authorities, arms length bodies and government - 30th April 2020
An update on current issues including avoiding legal challenge to procurement decisions, public decision making, state aid and commercial and supply chain.
Legal Update
The new State aid Temporary Framework
The new State aid Temporary Framework has been adapted by the European Commission due to the disruption that the coronavirus has caused.