Maughan judgment: Court of Appeal confirms that the civil standard of proof applies to suicide conclusions for inquests
On 10 May 2019 The Court of Appeal handed down judgment in R (Maughan) v HM Senior Coroner for Oxfordshire.
On 10 May 2019 The Court of Appeal handed down judgment in R (Maughan) v HM Senior Coroner for Oxfordshire.
The Court of Appeal has confirmed the ruling from the Divisional Court, and states that the only inquest conclusion to which the criminal standard of proof applies to is the unlawful killing conclusion. For all other inquest conclusions, it is the civil standard of proof that applies to factual findings and determinations, which includes findings of suicide.
So to be clear, for all findings and determinations (which includes conclusions) in inquests, the test to be applied is on the balance of probabilities, apart from unlawful killing which continues to be beyond reasonable doubt, the criminal standard.
The significance is that until recently a finding of suicide was subject to the criminal standard of proof. The result of this judgment is that coroners should not apply the higher standard of proof to reach a conclusion of suicide. Please note that the Court of Appeal has given permission for an appeal to the Supreme Court.
For further information, or to discuss this case, please do not hesitate to contact our inquest team.
Related expertise
You may be interested in...
Press Release
‘Privacy by design’ approach will help health and care organisations gain public trust in using technology as ICO publishes new guidance
Legal Update
Understanding the ICO's new fining guidance
Opinion - Maternity services
Newborns born outside of hospitals at higher risk of hypothermia during emergency responses
Guide
Demystifying international healthcare contracting
On-Demand
Shared Insights: Preparing and delivering organisational learning evidence in the Coroner’s Court
Legal Update
ICO consultation on accessing care records: A legal perspective
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights round up - Spring 2024
Legal Update
Court of Protection rules on capacity and best interests in pregnancy termination case involving detained woman
Online Event - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: focus on the Patient Safety Incident Response Framework (PSIRF)
Legal Update
Employment Healthcare Briefing - March 2024
Legal Update
The importance of including temporary staff in NHS patient safety investigations
Legal Update
Death certification reform in England and Wales – how will healthcare providers and commissioners be affected?
Opinion
Government’s Spring Budget invests millions in maternity safety
Opinion - Maternity services
Health Service Journal reports on growing trend of “free birthing”
Legal Update - Maternity services
Introduction of baby loss certificates gives recognition to millions of bereaved families in the UK
Legal Update
Charity law update – March 2024
Legal Update
NHS England publishes updated guidance on NHS subsidiary companies
Opinion
Caregivers at work: Navigating new carer's leave regulations
On-Demand - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Sexual safety in the workplace — how leaders can help to create a sexual safety culture
Opinion
EHRC publishes new guidance on menopause and the workplace
Legal Update - Health and Care Connect
Health and Care Connect: Health Check - March 2024
Legal Update
Braceurself Ltd v NHS England 2024: Court of Appeal procurement case decision
Legal Update
Mental health law round up – February 2024
Legal Update - Maternity services
Chesterfield Royal Hospital ranked amongst the top Trusts nationally in the 2023 Maternity Survey
Published Article
Planning the future of healthcare
On-Demand - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Giving evidence before the Family Court - a practical session
Legal Update
Updated guidance on COPDOL11 (Re X) applications
Opinion - Maternity services
Coronial investigations of stillbirths - summary of consultation responses
On-Demand - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Improving communication with families through the inquest process
Published Article
Legal frameworks for mental health
Press Release
Landmark Supreme Court decision clarifies the extent of Doctors’ Duty of Care
Press Release - Firm news
Browne Jacobson bolsters presence in Wales with three new appointments
Opinion
New employment rights set to come into force
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights round up - Winter 2023
Legal Update
Minimum Service Levels introduced for ambulance, rail, and border security
Opinion
BBC personality wins appeal on IR35 status
Opinion - Maternity services
BBC investigation finds NHS interpreting service problems contributed to baby deaths and serious brain injuries
Legal Update
Renewals and CTOs - are remote examinations permitted under the Mental Health Act?
Online Event
Mock inquest training sessions
