Maughan judgment: Court of Appeal confirms that the civil standard of proof applies to suicide conclusions for inquests
On 10 May 2019 The Court of Appeal handed down judgment in R (Maughan) v HM Senior Coroner for Oxfordshire.
On 10 May 2019 The Court of Appeal handed down judgment in R (Maughan) v HM Senior Coroner for Oxfordshire.
The Court of Appeal has confirmed the ruling from the Divisional Court, and states that the only inquest conclusion to which the criminal standard of proof applies to is the unlawful killing conclusion. For all other inquest conclusions, it is the civil standard of proof that applies to factual findings and determinations, which includes findings of suicide.
So to be clear, for all findings and determinations (which includes conclusions) in inquests, the test to be applied is on the balance of probabilities, apart from unlawful killing which continues to be beyond reasonable doubt, the criminal standard.
The significance is that until recently a finding of suicide was subject to the criminal standard of proof. The result of this judgment is that coroners should not apply the higher standard of proof to reach a conclusion of suicide. Please note that the Court of Appeal has given permission for an appeal to the Supreme Court.
For further information, or to discuss this case, please do not hesitate to contact our inquest team.
Related expertise
You may be interested in...
In Person Event
Mock Employment Tribunal
Online Event - Shared Insights
Shared Insights special: Fit for the future: 10 year health plan for England
Legal Update - Employment Rights Bill
The Employment Rights Bill: Is it here yet?
Legal Update
Building sustainable NHS-private sector partnerships: Expanding private patient units and beyond
Legal Update
NHS private patient units: Expanding via partnerships and key considerations
Legal Update
Top 10 considerations when expanding an NHS private patient unit
Legal Update
How to expand an NHS private patient unit: Practical guidance
Press Release
10-year health plan: Reaction from Browne Jacobson's health and life sciences team
Legal Update - Mindful insights
Mindful insights: June 2025
Opinion
Pride Month: A time to review DEI
Guide
Legal project management: A cornerstone in operational delivery of inquiries
Opinion
National maternity investigation launched: Enhancing care and addressing inequalities
Opinion
Employer redundancy guide: Sourcing alternative employment
Press Release - Firm news
Browne Jacobson delivers record-breaking growth as strategic vision drives exceptional performance
Legal Update
What might the public inquiry on child sexual exploitation look like
Press Release
Spending Review 2025: Browne Jacobson lawyers respond to Chancellor’s announcement
Legal Update
PPU roundtable 2: Advancing private patient units
Legal Update
Trans matters in health for trusts and acute settings: The decision in For Women Scotland
Legal Update
ESG and sustainability report: Rethinking communication and credibility
Press Release
Majority of UK organisations remain committed to sustainability and ESG, says new research
Legal Update
Producing robust capacity assessments and the approaches to assessing capacity
On-Demand - Care Focus webinar series
Care Focus: Critical incidents and managing risks
Online Event
Mental health and capacity forum: Navigating the transition from children to adults
Legal Update
Can those with a probate claim access a deceased patient’s records?
Press Release
UK-EU reset deal: Comments from Browne Jacobson experts
Opinion
Tackling inequalities in maternity care: NHS Providers' call for bold action
Opinion
Disciplinary procedures and mental health: Employer considerations
On-Demand
Shaping a culture of respect and harmony: Managing competing beliefs
Published Article
Anonymity injunctions for clinicians
Legal Update
Celebrating diversity and inclusion in the NHS: Equality, Diversity, and Human Rights Week 2025
Legal Update
Supporting mental wellbeing in the workplace: Practical steps for businesses
On-Demand - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Perils and pitfalls of social media in the health and care sector
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advises Apiary Capital on investment in pharmaceutical marketing agency PIO
On-Demand - Care Focus webinar series
Care Focus: Critical incident inquests
Press Release - Firm news
Browne Jacobson appoints Bethan Parry as Partner in health and litigation team
Opinion
Maternal Mental Health Awareness 2025
Opinion
High Court declares it lawful for a mental health trust not to impose treatment on a detained patient
Legal Update
A New chapter for families: Reflecting on the first month of the introduction of neonatal care leave
Legal Update
Trans matters in care: The decision in For Women Scotland
