W (No.3) GP (Nominee A ) Ltd and another v J D Sports Fashion Plc (Nottingham County Court, 22 October 2021)
The County Court refuses the landlord’s request to include a turnover rent in a statutory lease renewal.
The County Court refuses the landlord’s request to include a turnover rent in a statutory lease renewal.
Facts
This case concerned a lease renewal of retail premises in a shopping centre in Derby under Part II of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (the 1954 Act).
The landlord (W) had served a section 25 notice on the tenant (JDS) terminating its existing lease in June 2017. Under the existing lease, JDS was liable to pay an initial base rent of £175,000 and a turnover rent equivalent to the amount by which 8% of gross sales exceeded the base rent.
W wanted to include a similar turnover rent in the statutory renewal lease, whereas JDS wanted a fixed annual rent.
Issue
- Did section 34 of the 1954 Act (the section dealing with rent payable on a lease renewal) give the court jurisdiction to determine a turnover rent?
- Should a turnover rent be awarded in this case?
Decision
- A turnover rent is tenant specific and depends on the turnover of a particular tenant and the nature of its business. It therefore sits uneasily with the concept of a willing hypothetical tenant envisaged by section 34 for the purposes of calculating an open market rent.
Where the parties do not agree on a turnover rent, the court should assess (on the facts of the individual case) whether a turnover rent is appropriate. In some cases, where the nature of the business is clear, the likely turnover is discernible and the disregards in section 34 (the tenant’s occupation and the goodwill attached to its business) are of little or no relevance, a turnover rent may be appropriate. An example of this might be in a lease of a car park.
- A review of the comparable lettings in this shopping centre showed that the terms of the lettings were largely determined by the wishes of the particular tenant and that rents had decreased over recent years. A turnover rent in these circumstances was unlikely therefore to result in an open market rent (which is what section 34 requires) and was not appropriate. The court ordered a fixed rent in the renewal lease.
Point to note/consider
Whilst in this case it was W who was arguing for a turnover rent, in recent times the situation may often be reversed. To protect itself against future pandemics, lockdowns and government restrictions, a tenant who currently pays a fixed rent may want to move on renewal to a turnover rent, so that the risk of such events happening in the future is shared with its landlord.
Whilst this is only a County Court decision (and therefore has no precedent value), this decision does seem to indicate that, at least in a retail context (where the identity of the individual tenant and its business are key), a court is unlikely to be in a position to order a turnover rent on a statutory lease renewal (unless the parties agree).
Contact

David Harris
Professional Development Lawyer
david.harris@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)115 934 2019
Related expertise
You may be interested in...
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advise Cubo on investment to support expansion
Opinion
The long-awaited Renters Reform Bill is finally introduced into Parliament
Legal Update
Utilising prime retail sites to improve the health of our nation
Legal Update
Retirement housing: A solution to our care and housing crises?
Legal Update
A new era of opportunity for high street regeneration?
Opinion
Practical points from High Court ruling that Tesco has infringed Lidl’s IP rights in its famous yellow circle logo
Article
Interest from Asia boosts investor confidence in UK commercial real estate
Opinion
The UK market offers the best value for commercial real estate
Opinion
New provisions for higher-risk residential buildings now in force
Legal Update
Regeneration: what role can universities play?
Legal Update
Pitfalls for retailers to avoid when offering access to ‘buy now, pay later’ products
Opinion
Biodiversity Net Gain - Government publishes its metric consultation response & Natural England publishes their update biodiversity metric 4.0
Press Release
UK and Ireland law firm Browne Jacobson joins UKREiiF 2023
Press Release
Browne Jacobson’s Manchester dealmakers advise Spatial Global on its acquisition of Heathrow based freight specialist Hollyport Logistics
Legal Update
Biodiversity Net Gain — Government publishes consultation response
Opinion
‘Awaab’s Law’- a significant amendment to the Social Housing Regulation Bill
Press Release
Browne Jacobson’s real estate specialists advise Chesterfield Borough Council on prestigious new development - One Waterside Place
Opinion
Will fixed recoverable costs in housing conditions claims see the light of day?
Legal Update
J A Ball Limited (in Administration) v St Philips Homes (Courthaulds) Ltd
Opinion
“A Modern Nuisance”
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advise High Peak Borough Council on future high street funded acquisition as part of Buxton regeneration vision
Opinion
Supreme court rules on retail tenant's service charge bill
Guide
2023: Horizon scanning in construction
Legal Update
The importance of understanding the transitional provisions under the Electronic Communications Code
Legal Update
Biodiversity Net Gain: positive for nature and an opportunity for landowners
Published Article
Consumer duty part 3 - 'The drill-down' into the 'cross-cutting' rules
On-Demand
The UK's green agenda - the outcomes of COP27 and actions since COP26
Legal Update
Hillside – the end of drop in applications?
On 2 November 2022, the Supreme Court handed down its judgment in the much awaiting case of Hillside Parks Ltd v Snowdonia National Park Authority [2022] UKSC 30. The Court’s judgment suggests that the long established practice of using drop-in applications is in fact much more restricted than previously thought. This judgment therefore has significant implications for both the developers and local planning authorities.
Press Release
Browne Jacobson’s retail lawyers advise Wilko on its strategic £48m sale and leaseback of Nottinghamshire distribution centre to DHL
National law firm Browne Jacobson has advised long standing retail client, Wilko on the sale and leaseback of its Nottinghamshire distribution centre in Worksop to logistics specialist DHL for £48m.
Press Release
Suzanne Harlow joins Browne Jacobson as Non-Executive Director
Law firm Browne Jacobson is pleased to announce that Suzanne Harlow has been appointed Non-Executive Director of its Retail, Consumer & Logistics sector.
Legal Update
Is this the end for free returns?
Earlier in the year a number of fashion retailers, boldly announced the introduction of a charging fee for returning any product purchased via their online store. Yet, despite this commercial, and perhaps somewhat controversial decision, at least one major fashion giant that adopted this approach has recorded ‘historic highs’ in its September profits. Browne Jacobson partner, Cat Driscoll who heads up the firm’s commercial team in Manchester and is also head of its Fashion & Beauty sector discusses whether this change has put the average consumer off and whether the days of free returns are long gone.
Published Article
AI generated designs on retail products
Every AI will have its own terms of use. DALL·E 2’s Terms of Use dated 3 November 2022 specify that as between a user and Open AI, a user owns their prompts and uploads. Open AI also assigns to the user all rights in any images generated by DALL·E 2 for that user (subject to the user complying with those Terms of Use, and to a licence to use inputs and output to develop and improve the services).
Press Release
Former Mace Group Legal Director joins Browne Jacobson as Non-Executive Director of its Construction & Real Estate sector
Browne Jacobson has appointed Amy Chapman, the former Group Legal Director of global built environment experts Mace Group, as its first Non-Executive Director (NED) of its Construction & Real Estate sector strategy board.
Published Article
Consumer duty part 2 - 'The drill-down' into the 'cross-cutting' rules
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advises Bromley Council on the first social housing initiative of its kind to tackle homelessness
Published Article
Luxury brands and sustainability – The challenges and solutions
Legal Update
The Retained EU Law
Created at the end of the Brexit transition period, Retained EU Law is a category of domestic law that consists of EU-derived legislation retained in our domestic legal framework by the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018. This was never intended to be a permanent arrangement as parliament promised to deal with retained EU law through the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (the “Bill”).
Opinion
Rent arrears post-Covid: What are the landlord’s options?
Since the beginning of the pandemic, landlords and tenants have experienced significant limitations in the way rent arrears could be pursued. We first saw the moratorium on the recovery of Covid related arrears, and more recently we’ve experienced the implementation of the Covid arrears arbitration scheme.