Skip to main content
Share via Share via Share via Copy link

Mindful insights: November 2026

17 November 2026
Mark Barnett and Katie Viggers

Welcome to our dedicated mental health, mental capacity, deprivation of liberty and inquests newsletter, where we bring you significant updates and case law developments in these complex and compelling areas.

In this November edition of Mindful insights, we look at how the courts are applying the new deprivation of liberty framework following AGNI, explore the Townsend Court of Appeal principles in practice as well as the forthcoming Supreme Court appeal, and introduce our new Mental Health Act hub.

We also consider latest developments on assisted dying, explore patient safety lessons from the Thirlwall Inquiry, highlight the Chief Coroner’s standardised PFD response template and share upcoming training and events. 

In this edition

We welcome questions about any areas mentioned in our newsletter, as well as feedback on topics you would like us to cover. 

Contact us


Next mental health and capacity forum

Recent case law update

1 December 2026, 9:30am to 10:30am

Our next mental health and capacity forum will be hosted by Mark Barnett, Partner, and Laura Thomas, Associate. We will provide an update on recent mental health and capacity cases heard in both the High Court and Court of Protection, including decisions following the Supreme Court’s AGNI judgment, and explore the implications for your practice.

Register now


Key insights

Townsend 'best interests' appeal to be heard by the Supreme Court in January 2027

The Supreme Court is due to hear the Townsend v Epsom and St Helier University Hospitals NHS Trust appeal in January 2027. Our recent article examines the Court of Appeal judgment, the key issue before the Supreme Court and the implications for NHS bodies and commissioners. It also considers Cardiff and Vale University Health Board v ST, demonstrating how the principles established in Townsend have been applied in practice.

Read more

Hillsborough Law progressing through House of Lords

The Public Office (Accountability) Bill, known as the Hillsborough Law, is progressing through the House of Lords after completing its Commons stages in July 2026. It creates a statutory duty of candour and assistance for public authorities and officials when engaging with inquiries, inquests, and investigations, and introduces non-means tested legal aid for bereaved families where a public authority is an interested person at an inquest. A panel of experienced coroners will explore its practical implications at a Shared Insights session on 24 November.

Find out more and register

Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill defeated in House of Commons

The Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, which was re-introduced to the House of Commons by Lauren Edwards MP in June 2026, has been defeated at Second Reading. Following a debate in which both sides made emotional speeches, the House of Commons voted 286 to 270 – a majority of 16 – against the proposed legislation. For now, the Bill will make no further progress.

Read more

Thirlwall inquiry: Patient safety first

The Thirlwall Inquiry has published its report and recommendations on events at the Countess of Chester Hospital between 2015 and 2018, following Lucy Letby’s convictions for murdering and attempting to murder babies. It found that warning signs were missed, reputation took priority over patient safety and incident reporting systems were not fit for purpose. Its central message is that patient safety must always come first.

Read more


Deprivation of liberty

After AGNI: How are the courts applying the new multifactorial test?

Following the Supreme Court’s decision in AGNI, emerging judgments are showing what the new approach to deprivation of liberty looks like in practice. Our article examines several recent cases, illustrating how outcomes turn on the individual’s circumstances and experience of restrictions. It also highlights the “Salford checklist” as a practical assessment tool and explains why a lack of consent does not, by itself, establish a deprivation of liberty where the objective element of confinement is not met.

Read more


Mental capacity and safeguarding

Mental capacity, care and consent

Our September Shared Insights session explored mental capacity, care and consent, with a focus on applying the relevant legal frameworks in practice. We were joined by a fantastic panel of external speakers, who discussed treatment refusal on religious grounds, neglect and self-neglect, deprivation of liberty following AGNI and best interests disputes.

Read more

Child sexual abuse claims: Scope of the new limitation regime

In KHX v Isle of Wight Council [2026] EWHC 1949 (KB), the High Court considered the scope of the new limitation provisions for abuse claims introduced by the Crime and Policing Act 2026. The court confirmed that the new provisions apply only to the sexual abuse elements of a claim in which both sexual and physical abuse are alleged. Our article examines the judgment and its implications for organisations facing historical abuse claims. 

Read more


Mental health

Mental Health Act hub

The Mental Health Act 2025 received Royal Assent on 18 December 2025 and will significantly reform the 1983 Act in England and Wales. Implementation will be phased over several years, with only a few provisions in force so far. Our new Mental Health Act hub provides an overview of key changes, a commencement timeline, and detailed, themed analysis of the reforms. We will update the hub as further provisions come into force.

Visit the hub


Inquests

The Chief Coroner has published her annual report for 2025. Key developments include an updated Prevention of Future Deaths (PFD) publication policy and a new standardised template for responding to PFD reports. The template aims to promote clarity, ensure that organisational responses address the coroner’s concerns directly and transparently, and support consistency and good practice across organisations and sectors.

PFD response template

Updated PFD Publication Policy


Spotlight on Dan Taylor

Principal Associate, Cardiff

In this edition, we shine a spotlight on Dan Taylor, Principal Associate in our Cardiff office. Dan shares how he found his way into mental health and capacity law, his passion for the Welsh language and a surprising former role.

Read more

Contact

Contact

Mark Barnett

Partner

mark.barnett@brownejacobson.com

+44 (0)330 045 2515

View profile Connect on LinkedIn
Can we help you? Contact Mark

Katie Viggers

Senior Professional Development Lawyer

katie.viggers@brownejacobson.com

+44 (0)330 045 2157

View Profile
Can we help you? Contact Katie

You may be interested in...