An issue that is currently in the spotlight is the use of Reinforced Autoclaved Aerated Concrete (RAAC) in schools constructed between the 1950s and 1990s. Last week, just before the start of the new school term, the government closed affected schools pending further investigation and mitigation works. However, this issue has been actively monitored by the government since at least 2018, when a roof containing RAAC spontaneously collapsed in a school in Kent, which prompted the Standing Committee on Structural Safety (SCOSS) to issue an alert.
The recent school closures have been triggered by three further incidents involving RAAC, which had previously been considered low risk, at another school over the summer holidays. Therefore, all schools identified with RAAC (currently 150 and counting) have now been deemed potentially dangerous, leading to complete or partial closure. A further 5% of schools / responsible bodies are yet to complete their building surveys.
The issue is not restricted to schools, with reports of hospitals, courts, MOD buildings, concert halls and sports stadia in the public and commercial sectors, potentially containing RAAC. There is also the risk of the presence of RAAC in the residential sector – where ex-council houses, high-rise flats and converted former office buildings may also potentially be affected.
This might quickly become the next big issue in the construction industry, following the problems with asbestos and then cladding, in what is an aging – and quite literally crumbling – stock of buildings throughout the UK.
What is RAAC and why is its use problematic?
RAAC is a cementitious building material that is largely comprised of air (think of the texture of frothy milk, or bubbly chocolate!), with structural rebar support beams, usually made from steel. It is lightweight and therefore much quicker, easier and cheaper to construct and install. The latest Government guidance states: “RAAC panels may be present in floors, walls and roofs (pitched and flat) of buildings constructed or modified between the 1950s and 1990.”
The fundamental downside is that it has issues with durability – water ingress significantly weakens the structure - and in any event, a limited lifespan of approximately 30 years. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) has reported: “RAAC is now life-expired. It is liable to collapse with little or no notice.”
RAAC has a variety of uses, but the problems that are currently arising are largely from its use as a flat roof material. Added to this, on a flat roof, RAAC was often coated in bitumen which creates a waterproof seal. The lifespan of bitumen is typically a mere 15 years meaning such roofs will quickly fail to be watertight if not maintained. That in turn can lead to corrosion of the structural rebars and pooling of rainwater, leading to ingress and sagging, adding increased load until the roof spontaneously collapses.
Insurance response and potential coverage issues
This leads to interesting policy coverage questions over how property damage claims arising from the failure of RAAC might be treated. There will be questions over whether such claims would be covered, where the issue is one of either inherent design defect or gradually operating causes or damage caused by poor maintenance. Damage caused by water ingress, on the other hand, is often covered.
Investigations into the building materials used, the history of any maintenance schedules and what precisely was the cause of the collapse is likely to be key. Depending upon the wording, all damage arising out of the incident may be excluded. Alternatively, the costs of the roof repair may be excluded, but any damage caused to other parts of the building may be covered. The precise wording will be key.
It may well be that the availability of cover will be determined by the extent to which exclusions are limited to proximate causes or are sufficiently broad to capture indirect causes.
Read our proximate causes update
Longer term implications
We will be watching with interest to see how the government grapples with this latest issue, and whether it will trigger an expansion of the existing legal framework given the historical nature of this problem.
Whether this is left to the courts to deal with (as was the case with the BI losses arising from the pandemic in FCA v Arch and other satellite litigation) or whether there is an extension to the Building Safety Act 2022 (currently applying only to dwellings) to capture issues arising out of the RAAC crisis are two options that may be considered. We fully expect the Government to consult with insurers once the initial impact has been assessed.
This issue might become a double whammy for insurers, with the risk that subsequent professional negligence claims against a whole host of property professionals may follow – including building surveyors, estate managers and construction specialists – the list goes on.
Limitation is likely to form an important defence, and the 15 year long stop under Section 14B of the Limitation Act 1980 is likely to be an important shield to such claims – that is unless a cause of action under the Building Safety Act 2022 can be formulated, in which case limitation may be extended to up to 30 years.
We will report further as the situation develops.
You may be interested in...
Legal Update
Extreme weather leading to a rise in property claims
Published Article
RAAC: 5 questions to guide investigations
Legal Update
Reinforced Autoclaved Aerated Concrete ('RAAC') implications for schools
Legal Update
The recent judgment in MacPhail v Allianz Insurance Plc
Published Article
Action needed: How RAAC became a critical issue
Legal Update
Insurance considerations of RAAC failures - air bubbles belong in chocolate, not concrete!
Legal Update
100+ schools told to close immediately due to threat of Reinforced Autoclaved Aerated Concrete
Legal Update
The RAAC crisis: Is it really back-to-school this September?
Legal Update
School building safety is ‘a critical risk’
Legal Update
Assured shorthold tenancies for schools… let them have it!
Legal Update
A ‘slick’ result for Shell: the Supreme Court considers limitation in Jalla v Shell
Legal Update
Parties are in hot water over hot works dispute: proceedings issued in Britannia Hotels (No.2) v Aviva Insurance Limited
Legal Update
The perfect financial storm: top 5 trends making a mischief with BI adjustments
Legal Update
COVID-19 BI Claims rumble on
Legal Update
The risk of encroachment is not a nuisance: Davies v Bridgend County Council
Legal Update
Visual intrusion is oppressive: Fearn v Tate Gallery
Legal Update
Proximate cause focus: Brian Leighton Garages v Allianz and Allianz v University of Exeter
Legal Update
Perils - May 2023
Guide
FAQs – academy re-brokerage
Legal Update
It’s “Bomb’s Away” for Allianz as they receive a declaration on proximate cause: Allianz Insurance Plc v University of Exeter
Legal Update
“Being on display in a zoo” is oppressive for luxury flat owners as the Tate Modern is found to be liable in nuisance
Legal Update
Court of Appeal considers ‘proximate cause’ for Pollution or Contamination exclusion in All Risks policy
Opinion
Implementation of the Fire Safety (England) Regs 2022
Guide
FAQs - converting to academy status
Press Release
Law firm picks up record breaking sixth Education Investor Award
Browne Jacobson’s education team has been named as winner of the ‘Legal Advisors to Education Institutions’ category at the Education Investor Awards 2022 for a record sixth time.
Press Release
Thousands take part in virtual careers event to help increase diversity in the legal profession
Over 3000 young people from across the UK and Ireland took part in a virtual legal careers insight event, aimed at making the legal profession more diverse.
Legal Update
The Ukraine War: Aviation and cyber issues
Legal Update
Browne Jacobson’s market leading Education expertise recognised again in latest Legal 500 rankings
The new set of Legal 500 directory rankings have been published and we are proud to once again be recognised as one of the country’s leading firms advising the Education sector.
Published Article
RAAC planks and its impact on local authorities
Recent reports of flat roofs constructed using RAAC planks collapsing without warning prompted the SCOSS alert.
Legal Update
Court of Appeal confirms exclusive English jurisdiction clause in excess liability policies in Canadian pipeline dispute
On 10 June 2022 the Court of Appeal upheld an anti-suit injunction granted in favour of insurers by Mr Justice Jacobs in September 2021 restraining proceedings from being brought in Canada and enforcing the exclusive English jurisdiction clause in excess liability policies.
Legal Update
Building cost increases and the impact of underinsurance
Press Release
Browne Jacobson’s C-suite exec level coaching team appoints two new education specialists
National law firm Browne Jacobson has grown its team behind its dedicated Space + Time executive coaching programme with the addition of two more qualified coaches who will work with clients in the education sector.
Opinion
Fines for unsafe removal of asbestos in schools
In order to reduce the risk of potential breaches, schools should follow this Health and Safety Executive guidance.
Press Release
Browne Jacobson hosts UK’s largest virtual legal careers event to boost access to careers in law
Press Release
New benchmarking service now available to guide the remuneration of school trust executive teams
The Confederation of School Trusts (CST), as the sector body for School Trusts, today releases a salary benchmarking service for executive roles in School Trusts, in conjunction with partners XpertHR, Cendex and Browne Jacobson.
Legal Update
Consultation opens on a revised Building Bulletin 100 design guide for fire safety in schools
Opinion
Government announces ten-year programme of school rebuilding
Ambitious funding plans, announced recently by the Prime Minister, have made clear that spending on school buildings is seen as a key element of efforts to stimulate the economy post-COVID.
Legal Update
Non-payment of insurance premiums during the Coronavirus pandemic
The forced closure of many businesses as a result of the Coronavirus pandemic has had a huge impact on the nation’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Recent reports from the Office for National Statistics state that the economy was 25% smaller in April than it was in February this year.
Legal Update
Reinstatement for property damage losses – when does it apply?
The Court of Appeal has recently considered the correct test for measuring the indemnity for property damage losses and has provided useful guidance on whether an insured needs to intend to reinstate the property to its pre-loss condition.
Legal Update
Coronavirus (COVID-19) insurance considerations
With instances of COVID-19 rapidly increasing throughout the UK, many businesses are considering the options available to limit staff and customer exposure to Coronavirus.