Does a breach of an obligation in an agreement for lease allow the tenant to refuse to complete the lease?
A tenant who does not want to be forced to complete a lease if an obligation in the agreement for lease is breached must provide expressly for this in the agreement.
A tenant who does not want to be forced to complete a lease if an obligation in the agreement for lease is breached must provide expressly for this in the agreement.
In a recent case, the agreement for lease prevented the landlord from making variations to the landlord’s works (the construction of student accommodation) which materially affected the size of the rooms. The agreement provided that a size reduction of more than 3% from the original drawings was deemed material. In contravention of this provision, the landlord built some rooms which were more than 3% smaller.
The Court of Appeal decided that although the parties could spell out exactly what type of breach would allow the tenant to terminate an agreement, that was not what the parties had done here and it would not make commercial sense if any breach of the agreed size tolerance level (e.g. an undersized bin store) automatically allowed the tenant to terminate the agreement.
In this case, the tenant is possibly facing the unpalatable prospect of having to complete a long lease of student accommodation with 56 rooms smaller than specified.
It makes sense to agree at heads of terms stage what breaches will give rise to termination so that both parties are clear from the outset and this can then be built into the agreement for lease.
Contact
David Harris
Professional Development Lawyer
david.harris@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)115 934 2019
Related expertise
You may be interested in...
Legal Update - Procurement Act
Procurement Bill: Competitive flexible procedure, how will this work in practice?
Legal Update - Procurement Act
Procurement Bill - Are they still playing ping-pong?
Press Release
Browne Jacobson collaborates with LGiU on report highlighting “critical” role of local government to hit net zero
Guide
Net Zero and Local Democracy: building and maintaining public support
Opinion
Vicarious liability of amateur sports teams for player on player injuries
Legal Update - Procurement Act
Procurement Act 2023: Getting Ready for Reform - the countdown is on!
Legal Update
Personal injury discount rate in England and Wales
Legal Update
Reinforced Autoclaved Aerated Concrete ('RAAC') implications for schools
Legal Update - Public matters newsletter
Public matters - September 2023
Legal Update
Fixed recoverable costs regime – are you ready?
Opinion
Parental alienation a tool for domestic abuse?
Opinion
£600m funding unveiled to boost social care workforce
Opinion
Are councils failing to tackle anti-social behaviour?
Press Release
Browne Jacobson announces appointment of Barrister to its Cardiff office
Legal Update
PPN 08/23: using standard contracts
Legal Update
Part 36 combined offers – when are they beaten?
Legal Update
Review of a subsidy control decision: The Durham Company Ltd v Durham County Council, 27 July 2023
Legal Update
Browne Jacobson grows Cardiff team with two new appointments
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advising the Welsh Government on the delivery of significant number of renewable energy projects
![Local authorities contracting out enforcement of debts - A review of the High Court’s judgment in Bailiffs Limited v Breckland Council [2023] EWHC 1569](/getattachment/69fe511b-7da4-4d9a-ac5b-f18436ce5fe2/gov-shutterstock_682694722-14.jpg?variant=HeroImageTabletVariantDefinition)
Legal Update
Local authorities contracting out enforcement of debts - A review of the High Court’s judgment in Bailiffs Limited v Breckland Council [2023] EWHC 1569
Opinion
Right to request flexible working – changes ahead for employers
Press Release
Browne Jacobson successfully defend vicarious liability claim appeal in connected person foster care case
Press Release - #BeingBrowneJacobson
Building our future town centres: advising local authorities on landmark acquisitions
Opinion
Are teacher strikes coming to an end?
Opinion
Further consultants strike announced following government pay offer
Opinion
Agency worker cover during strikes
Press Release
Browne Jacobson’s patent litigation team praised for being “dynamic” and a “major player” in IAM Patent 1000 guide
Legal Update
Employment alternative dispute resolution
Legal Update
Insolvency practitioners and trustee immunity
Guide
How to manage supply contracts and avoid disputes
Legal Update - Public matters newsletter
Public Matters - June 2023
Legal Update
What are we to do about self reporting in PFI contracts?
Legal Update
Guidance on contract changes: James Waste Management LLP v Essex County Council
Legal Update
Case summary: the importance of bringing a procurement claim within the appropriate time limits
Legal Update - Procurement Act
New obligations for Welsh public bodies on social partnership and socially responsible procurement
Legal Update
Public Consultation on a Mandatory Reporting Regime for Child Sexual Abuse
Legal Update
Top tips on tackling air pollution risk in a changing climate
Article
Challenging procurement decisions by way of Judicial Review - the key principles
Opinion
NHS announces artificial intelligence fund
