Workers are entitled to receive a minimum hourly rate of pay, the national minimum wage (NMW).
The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) decided in the case of Lloyd v Elmhurst School Limited [2022] that the Employment Tribunal (ET) had erred by finding that a term-time salaried hours worker was not entitled to the NMW for hours worked outside school term-time.
Ms Lloyd, a learning support assistant, worked three days a week during school terms and was paid her salary in monthly instalments. Ms Lloyd’s employment contract stated that she was entitled to “usual school holidays” as “holiday with pay”. Her contract did not include any provisions in respect of hours of work, her rate of pay for school holidays or her annual salary. She brought a claim for unlawful deduction from wages under the Employment Rights Act 1996, contending that she had not been paid the NMW. The question for the ET was whether Ms Lloyd’s basic hours should be calculated over 52 weeks or the 36 weeks she actually worked (plus four weeks of leave entitlement). The ET dismissed her claim on the basis that her basic hours for the purpose of regulation 21(3) of the National Minimum Wage Regulations 2015 (NMW Regulations) were based on 21 hours over 40 weeks, which were the 36 weeks she worked during school terms and her leave entitlement of four weeks under the Working Time Directive. The ET considered that the additional 12 weeks’ contractual holiday did not form part of her basic hours. Ms Lloyd appealed the ET’s decision.
The EAT held that the ET should have focussed on Ms Lloyd’s employment contract rather than the hours she had in fact worked. The EAT found that a worker’s basic hours do not depend on the hours actually worked, and basic hours can include periods of absence where contractual salary is due to be paid. It was wrong of the ET to focus on whether the Claimant was working outside school terms or not.
The EAT’s decision provides clarification on what is meant by “basic hours” within the meaning of regulation 21(3) of the NMW Regulations. Employers should identify a worker’s basic hours by using their employment contract, not the actual hours that they work. Employers should also take care to ensure the drafting of worker’s contracts are detailed and precise. In Ms Lloyd’s case, the wording of the clause in her contract was a key component of the EAT’s analysis of how her basic hours should be calculated.
Following the Supreme Court’s decision in Harpur Trust v Brazel [2022] this decision again places emphasis on the complexities relating to part-year workers.
You may be interested in...
Opinion
Can teachers personal and political views amount to misconduct?
Legal Update
Government updates guidance on holiday rules: What employers need to know
In Person Event
Optimus: HR update and people strategy
Legal Update
How do holiday pay reforms affect the education sector?
Legal Update
Revised Acas Code of Practice on requests for flexible working
Opinion
Settlement agreements: Court of Session finds future claims may be settled
Legal Update
Holiday reforms: What employers need to know
Legal Update
Employment law in 2024: How changes impact education
Legal Update
Backpay for leavers: Employers risk unlawful deduction from wages claims
Legal Update
School staff pay – how are academies responding to national recommendations?
Opinion
Autumn statement 2023 – key take outs for employers
Opinion
Agency cover and strike action
Opinion
Overcoming barriers: Building leadership resilience in MATs
Opinion
Updates in equality – An overview of new regulations
Opinion
Minimum Service Levels and reasonable steps – consultation response
Legal Update
Holiday entitlement and pay: Reforms ahead
Legal Update
A positive duty to prevent sexual harassment
Opinion
Minimum service levels and reasonable steps
Opinion
Are teacher strikes coming to an end?
Legal Update
Parental leave and pay - gender equality?
On-Demand
'School staffing restructures: practical guidance for implementing organisational change' webinar
Legal Update
Updates to the Burgundy Book
Published Article
Third Party Harassment – haven’t we been here before?
On-Demand
Flexible working in schools webinar
Legal Update
New report highlights risk of sidelining ED&I in school trusts
Legal Update
Teacher strikes – lessons learnt so far
Opinion
Term-time school worker entitled to national minimum wage for unworked basic hours
On-Demand
Industrial action essentials: what you need to know
Opinion
Menopause and the workplace
Legal Update
Trade unions announce plans to re-ballot members
Legal Update
Widespread industrial action now confirmed for schools
Legal Update
Industrial action and minimum service levels within education
Opinion
Consultation on holiday entitlement – part-year and irregular workers
Guide
FAQs - converting to academy status
Opinion
Rising Employment Tribunal backlog
Guide
Recruiting school staff on a budget – top tips
Regardless of the outcome of ballots on industrial action, unless there is drastic change to funding for schools in relation to pay increases, it will be unusual to find any organisational budget that is not impacted by the current economic situation.
Legal Update
Coming of age
Official statistics show that 15,336 claims which included a complaint of age discrimination were received at the Employment Tribunals between March 2020 and March 2021.
Opinion
World Cup 2022 – how employers can avoid scoring an own goal!
The World Cup kicks off in Qatar on Sunday 20 November 2022, with the final taking place on Sunday 18 December 2022. Undoubtedly, this is a huge sporting event, and many employees will be keen to show their support for their favourite teams. However, due to the time difference, start times for the matches are between 10 a.m. and 7 p.m. UK time, which could have an impact on employers if employees who wish to watch the matches are scheduled to work.
Press Release
Law firm picks up record breaking sixth Education Investor Award
Browne Jacobson’s education team has been named as winner of the ‘Legal Advisors to Education Institutions’ category at the Education Investor Awards 2022 for a record sixth time.
Press Release
Thousands take part in virtual careers event to help increase diversity in the legal profession
Over 3000 young people from across the UK and Ireland took part in a virtual legal careers insight event, aimed at making the legal profession more diverse.