Care home worker fairly dismissed for refusing Covid-19 vaccination
The Tribunal considered whether a care home worker was unfairly dismissed following her refusal to be vaccinated against Covid-19. It is important to note the Claimant’s dismissal pre-dated the compulsory vaccination regulations in force from November 2021.
In Allette v Scarsdale Grange Nursing Home Limited, the Tribunal considered whether a care home worker was unfairly dismissed following her refusal to be vaccinated against Covid-19. It is important to note the Claimant’s dismissal pre-dated the compulsory vaccination regulations in force from November 2021.
The Claimant was dismissed on the grounds that she had unreasonably refused to follow management instructions to get vaccinated in January 2021. The Claimant asserted her beliefs against the safety of the vaccine and that it would be against her Rastafarian beliefs to take non-natural medication. The Tribunal considered claims for wrongful and unfair dismissal.
The Tribunal found the Respondent had a legitimate aim when instructing employees to get vaccinated and for dismissing the Claimant who refused to comply, namely to protect the health and safety of residents, staff and visitors. The Tribunal found that although there was interference with the Claimant’s Article 8 Convention right (right to respect for her private life) in requiring her to have the vaccine, this was justified in the circumstances as the particular circumstances of this care home meant that the Article 8 rights of the residents and other staff and visitors were unjustly interfered with by the presence of the Claimant. The Respondent acted within the range of reasonable responses and dismissal was proportionate.
In relation to wrongful dismissal, the Tribunal found the Claimant’s fear and scepticism was an unsubstantiated belief, rather than a religious belief, and as she knew her actions represented a risk to others this was gross misconduct.
The decision is only first instance and is not binding, although it is a useful first look at how tribunals may deal with claims related to compulsory vaccination (including within employers where there is no legal mandate) and, in particular, the relevance of Convention rights.
Contact
Mark Hickson
Head of Business Development
onlineteaminbox@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)370 270 6000
Discover more
Related expertise
You may be interested in...
Guide
Resident doctors vote to strike: Key legal considerations for the NHS
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advises SKIMS on lease of a landmark Regent Street store
Legal Update
The Assisted Dying Bill: What health and social care professionals need to know
In Person Event
Private Patient Units: expanding through partnership – views from private sector providers
Online Event
Legal principles of workforce change management in the NHS and the people dimension
Legal Update
Significant amendments to the Employment Rights Bill unveiled
Legal Update
Consultation on the new School Support Staff Negotiating Body
Legal Update
What does the 10-year health plan mean for social care?
On-Demand - Care Focus webinar series
Care Focus: Critical incident - Reflection
Legal Update
The Government’s 10-Year Health Plan: What’s in it for mental health?
In Person Event
Mock Employment Tribunal
Guide
Inquests: How wide should the scope be? The coroner’s decision
Legal Update - Employment Rights Bill
The Employment Rights Bill: Is it here yet?
Legal Update
Building sustainable NHS-private sector partnerships: Expanding private patient units and beyond
Legal Update
NHS private patient units: Expanding via partnerships and key considerations
Legal Update
Top 10 considerations when expanding an NHS private patient unit
Legal Update
How to expand an NHS private patient unit: Practical guidance
Press Release
10-year health plan: Reaction from Browne Jacobson's health and life sciences team
Legal Update
The National Food Crime Unit: Will new powers make a difference to tackling food fraud?
Legal Update
Update on the Deposit Returns Scheme and the Deposit Management Organisation
Legal Update
Soft Drinks Industry Levy consultation
Legal Update
June 2025: A busy month for kinship care
Legal Update
The EU Deforestation Regulation: Implications and actions for the fashion industry
Legal Update - Mindful insights
Mindful insights: June 2025
Opinion
Pride Month: A time to review DEI
Guide
Legal project management: A cornerstone in operational delivery of inquiries
Opinion
National maternity investigation launched: Enhancing care and addressing inequalities
Legal Update
Analysis: National audit on group-based child sexual exploitation and abuse (June 2025)
Opinion
Employer redundancy guide: Sourcing alternative employment
Press Release - Firm news
Browne Jacobson delivers record-breaking growth as strategic vision drives exceptional performance
Legal Update
What might the public inquiry on child sexual exploitation look like
On-Demand - Shared Insights
Shared Insights safeguarding forum: Focus on self-neglect
Legal Update
DEI in school governance: Key themes and insights
Guide
Using AI for recruitment: The data issues
Guide
The socio-economic duty: Shifting mindsets for true social mobility
Press Release
Spending Review 2025: Browne Jacobson lawyers respond to Chancellor’s announcement
Legal Update
Charity law update, June 2025
Legal Update
PPU roundtable 2: Advancing private patient units
Legal Update
Trans matters in health for trusts and acute settings: The decision in For Women Scotland
