'Broken trust: making patient safety more than just a promise', published by the Parliamentary and Health Ombudsman Service (PHSO) on 29 June 2023, highlights that despite significant developments in patient safety over the last decade, there remains a gap between ambitious patient safety objectives and effective learning within a just and learning culture to prevent harm. The report also demonstrates the adverse impact that poor quality investigations and complaint responses can have on patients and their families in the aftermath of harm and how NHS organisations can make tangible improvements in this area.
Summary of findings
The PHSO undertook a detailed analysis of 22 NHS complaint investigations where it found a death was, more likely than not, avoidable and found four broad themes of clinical failings leading to avoidable death, namely:
- failures to make the right diagnosis.
- delays in providing treatment.
- poor handovers between clinicians.
- failure to listen to the concerns of patients or their families.
Secondly, the analysis showed that the physical harm experienced by patients was too often made worse by ‘inadequate, defensive and insensitive responses’ from NHS organisations when concerns were raised. Several factors contributed to the further distress (known as compounded harm) that can be caused by poor quality investigations and responses:
- a failure to be honest when things go wrong, including failures to comply with the duty of candour.
- a lack of support for patients and families to navigate systems after an incident.
- poor-quality investigations with examples or organisations failing to undertake thorough investigations and/or accept errors or the extent of what has happened and its impact.
- a failure to respond to complaints in a timely and compassionate way with examples of complaint response letters containing inaccurate and/or contradictory information.
- inadequate apologies.
- unsatisfactory learning responses.
Changes to patient safety incident response under the Patient Safety Incident Response Framework (PSIRF)
The PHSO report comes at a time of significant change for the way in which NHS Trusts respond to patient safety incidents with the transition to the PSIRF which, once fully implemented, will replace the Serious Incident Framework (2015). Giving Trusts more autonomy to decide when a Patient Safety Incident Investigation (PSII) is needed, the PSIRF prompts a move away from a reactive and bureaucratic approach to incident investigation to a more proactive approach to learning and responding to harm.
Much has been written about the positive changes and improvements to learning that the PSIRF will bring about. The PHSO tempers this positivity, flagging caution about the need for accountability and monitoring of the new framework, stating that "it holds great promise but needs to be accompanied by sufficient monitoring and better support for families".
Specifically, the PHSO flags that the additional flexibility the PSIRF offers (enabling individual organisations to determine which incidents to investigate), brings a risk that Trusts with poor cultures may not carry out safety incident investigations when they should.
Recommendations
Recognising the complexity of the healthcare system and the fragmentation of the patient safety landscape, the PHSO makes it clear that another patient safety body or initiative is not what is needed. Instead, it calls for a streamlined system that works together, with real leadership from Government with recommendations which focus on two areas:
1. Accountability for a robust and compassionate response to harm, which supports learning for systems and healing for families
- Integrated care boards, with oversight from NHS England, should closely monitor the impact of the PSIRF, paying special attention to the balance of patient safety investigations versus other learning responses in Trusts (or service areas of a Trust) where there are poor CQC ratings for safety and leadership, or where other national bodies have raised concerns (recommendation 1).
- The PSIRF executive lead on each Board should look at any discrepancies between local and PHSO investigations, or other independent investigations, and make sure the Board discusses them (recommendation 2).
- The Department of Health and Social Care and NHS England should further scrutinise the lack of compliance with duty of candour. They should review the operation of duty of candour to assess its effectiveness and make recommendations for improvement (recommendation 3).
- The Department of Health and Social Care should commit to funding further independent advocacy to support harmed patients, families and carers when they raise concerns or seek answers after an incident (recommendation 4)
2. Evidencing that patient safety is a top Government and NHS priority
- The Department of Health and Social Care should commission an independent review of what an effective set of patient safety oversight bodies would look like. The review must include meaningful engagement with NHS leaders, staff, patients and families (recommendation 5).
- The Government should seek cross-party support for commitments to embedding patient safety and the culture and leadership needed to support it as a long-term priority (recommendation 6).
- The Government should urgently produce its long-awaited long-term workforce strategy, with cross-party support, to increase the numbers entering and staying in the workforce across clinical and non-clinical roles (in fact, a day after the publication of the PHSO report, the NHS long-term workforce plan was published) (recommendation 7).
Comment
The findings set out in 'Broken trust: making patient safety more than just a promise' do not reveal any new themes but the report does highlight the disconnect between best practice policy and the reality of front-line practice. With the imminent implementation of the PSIRF and considerable activity underway to change the way NHS Trusts approach incident investigation, the report is a reminder of the ongoing challenges to improving learning where the people and complex systems that make up the NHS are under significant and growing pressure.
To this end, the PHSO report makes it clear that the PSIRF is not a silver bullet. Achieving a culture of candour remains at the heart of success and yet the PHSO found recent examples of poor complaint responses, inadequate apologies and shortcomings in implementing the duty of candour. These are all areas where Trusts (and other healthcare organisations) can make significant improvement by supporting front line staff to understand not only the legal obligations but also the impact of engaging with patients and their families in a timely and sensitive way and providing written responses which are easy to understand and compassionate in tone.
There are various resources available for organisations to support staff in this area including the NHS Resolution duty of candour animation and Saying Sorry guidance, which makes it clear that saying sorry is not an admission of liability.
Our specialist organisational learning team delivers training on duty of candour (achieving a culture of candour) and resolving complaints to support the early resolution of complaints in an effective and compassionate way. We have also developed a number of resources to support Trusts with the transition to the PSIRF which may be of interest to you:
Shared Insights: The Patient Safety Incident Response Framework
Shared Insights: PSIRF and what it means for Independent Providers
PSIRF support and training packages
Please contact us if you would like to discuss how we can support your organisation.
Contact

Amelia Newbold
Risk Management Lead
Amelia.Newbold@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)115 908 4856
You may be interested in...
Online Event - Shared Insights
Shared Insights with Irwin Mitchell: Improving communication with patients and families
Legal Update
Improving patient safety incident and complaint responses to rebuild broken trust
Published Article
Digital channels and healthcare apps – the UK’s regulatory landscape, challenges for stakeholders and risk of clinical liabilities
Legal Update
Learning from Reports to Prevent Future Deaths in Mental Health settings - A Review of PFDs nationally 2022-2023
Online Event
Mock Inquest Training Sessions
Legal Update
LPS consultation and ‘go live’ planning
On-Demand
Leadership and lessons learnt during the Pandemic by Professor Jonathan Van-Tam
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: The Patient Safety Incident Response Framework
Guide - Maternity services
Mediation guide for Clinicians: What do you need to know and how do you need to prepare
Opinion - Maternity services
Baby Loss Awareness Week
On Saturday 15 October a wave of light swept the internet when thousands of people flooded social media with pictures of candles to remember the babies that they have lost. This event signifies the end of Baby Loss Awareness Week which aims to break the silence that is associated with baby loss in pregnancy and infancy.
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Focus on emergency medicine
In our latest Shared Insights session, Focus on Emergency Medicine, chaired by Jennifer Fagin and Amelia Newbold, we were pleased to be joined by: Dr Alex Crowe, Deputy Director Incentive Schemes & Academic Partnerships, NHS Resolution and Consultant Nephrologist and Miss Susie Hewitt MBE, Consultant in Emergency Medicine, University Hospitals of Derby and Burton NHS Foundation Trust.
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: The Fitness to Practise Regime
In this session, our speakers discussed the Fitness to Practise Regime and how we can help.
Legal Update
Health and Care Regulation – The Present and the Future
In this article, we discuss some of the themes we have seen in recent CQC regulation as well as providing an update on the development of their new assessment framework. I will also highlight other key developments in the sector that all providers should be aware of.
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Coroners' Question Time
In this session, our speakers discussed fundamentals of disclosure, general points on disclosure & Post-Pandemic, interested Persons & Patient Safety Incident Response, and how we can help & Takeaway Tips.
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Overview of inquests in relation to deaths in custody
In this session, our speakers discussed gave an overview of inquests in relation to deaths in custody and discussed three key themes; Documentation Provision, Communication, and Decision making. They also discussed Healthcare in a prison setting - manging the unique challenges.
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: The impact of Ockenden and implementation of the IEAs from ward to Board
In this session, our speakers discussed the final Ockenden report, the Midwifery Perspective, the Board Perspective, and the Wider national initiatives - Monitoring May.
Opinion
Learning from Emergency Medicine compensation claims
Every year a high number of patients attend Emergency Departments (EDs) in England, often presenting with complex and wide-ranging symptoms. Many of these challenges were explored in the Getting It Right First Time Emergency Medicine Report, published in 2021.
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Medical Mediation in Health and Social Care
In this session, our speakers discussed recognising and managing conflict, the benefits of mediation and the practicalities, and the safety and learning perspective.
Legal Update - Maternity services
The Ockenden Final Report – a blueprint for safe maternity care from ward to Board
The much anticipated final Ockenden report was published on 30 March 2020. The final report sets out the findings of the review into care provided to 1,486 families, and sets out a blueprint for safe maternity care.
Opinion
Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust and Purchase v Ahmed
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Safeguarding Forum - Safe discharge and conveyance of patients
It is important to bear in mind the legal framework when planning discharge and conveyance plans but practicalities are also key.
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Managing violent, abusive and racist patients
Rebecca Fitzpatrick, Helen Badger and Carl May-Smith, Partners at Browne Jacobson provided an overview of the legal frameworks in place that can assist Trusts when managing violent, abusive and racist patients
Training - Maternity services
Maternity mock inquest - film 1
Consent is often a key issue in obstetric claims and if it is relevant to the facts of the death, its likely to be an area explored by a coroner.
Training - Maternity services
Maternity mock inquest - film 2
This video illustrates some of the issues that can arise when a witness is poorly prepared.
Training - Maternity services
Maternity mock inquest - film 3
This film highlights the importance of creating an open and transparent culture where staff feel able to speak up will help Trusts to identify problematic practise before significant issues arise.
Legal Update
CQC’s strategy from 2021 launch - an interesting start but much more to come
Legal Update
Care Quality Commission (CQC) prosecution outcomes highlight ongoing trends
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared insights: The Paterson Inquiry: learning for the healthcare system
Implications for in-house legal, patient safety, clinical governance, workforce culture and large-scale reviews.
Training - Shared Insights
Giving evidence at a Coroner’s inquest – guidance for clinical witnesses
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: The impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on consent
Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015], the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic, patients who lack capacity to make a particular decision and data on consent claims.
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: External investigations and prosecutions in the NHS
The steps organisations should take if they are subject to an investigation by the police, Health and Safety Executive or CQC.
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Preparing for remote inquest hearings and dealing with inquests in a pandemic
Guidance for NHS Trusts on how to prepare for remote inquests.
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: Learning from claims - effective triangulation of data
Focused on effective triangulation of data and learning from claims.
Legal Update - Shared Insights
Shared Insights: NHS whistleblowing post Covid-19 – common pitfalls and best practice
We speak about law protecting whistleblowers, how to recognise a protected disclosure and the Trust’s statutory duties when dealing with whistleblowers.
Training
CQC and health and care regulatory update - June 2019
Carl-May Smith provides an enforcement and prosecutions update including looking at recent prosecutions of Registered Managers.