0370 270 6000

Poundland Ltd v Toplain Ltd [Brentford County Court, 7 April 2021]

5 October 2021

The County Court refuses to sanction the inclusion of a pandemic rent suspension clause in a non-contested lease renewal.

Facts

This case concerned a non-contested lease renewal under Part II of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (1954 Act).

The parties had reached agreement on an annual rent of £130,000 for a new five-year term with no break clause. However, amongst the changes from the existing lease sought by the tenant (P) was the inclusion of a pandemic rent suspension clause which would reduce the rent and service charge payable by 50% if there was a government imposed lockdown. The landlord (L) resisted this on the basis that there was no market precedent for this drafting and that it would fundamentally change the parties' relationship.

Issue

Was the inclusion of a pandemic rent suspension clause a fair and reasonable amendment to make to the terms of the existing lease (as required by the principles set out by the House of Lords in the case of O'May v City of London Real Property Co Ltd [1983] 2 AC 726)?

Decision

The inclusion of a pandemic rent suspension clause would not be fair and reasonable in the circumstances. The purpose of the 1954 Act was not to rewrite previously negotiated risks, even though the parties had not considered a national lockdown when negotiating the existing lease. It would be unreasonable to impose a sharing of the risk on L in circumstances over which L would have no control, especially as government reliefs or schemes may give P some control over the risk.

Points to note/consider

The judge in this case distinguished it from the decision reported a few months earlier (WH Smith Retail Holdings Ltd v Commerz Real Investmentgesellschaft mbh). In that case, the parties had already agreed that a pandemic rent suspension clause should be included in the renewal lease and the court was simply determining what the appropriate trigger for its operation should be.

As county court cases, neither has any precedent value. However, given how common requests for pandemic rent suspension clauses have become on the grant of new leases, it seems likely that this issue will be considered by the higher courts in the foreseeable future.

Focus on...

Legal updates

Regeneration funding: Securing Compulsory Purchase Orders in the face of escalating building costs

The focus on the Levelling Up agenda and the availability of grant funding, means there are numerous important regeneration schemes actively being pursued across the country. With ever-escalating project and building costs, in many cases, applications that were made for grant funding were based on costs contingencies that have already been exceeded.

View

Blogs

Cameras in convenience stores: a potential hornet’s nest..?

A convenience retailer has opted to install cameras (the “Facewatch” system) at a limited number of its English stores to reduce crime and protect its staff.

View

Press releases

Browne Jacobson advises Birmingham City Council on its £26.4m acquisition of ‘best in class’ building 9 Colmore Row

Browne Jacobson’s real estate lawyers have advised longstanding client, Birmingham City Council on its acquisition of 70,000 sq ft building, 9 Colmore Row, located in the heart of Birmingham’s central business district.

View

Blogs

Covid Rent Arrears: Cinema operators’ appeals dismissed

The Court of Appeal has dismissed two cases regarding rent arrears accrued during the Covid lockdowns. The cases are London Trocadero (2015) LLP v Picturehouse Cinemas Ltd and Bank of New York Mellon (International) Ltd v Cine-UK Ltd.

View

The content on this page is provided for the purposes of general interest and information. It contains only brief summaries of aspects of the subject matter and does not provide comprehensive statements of the law. It does not constitute legal advice and does not provide a substitute for it.

David Harris

David Harris

Professional Development Lawyer

View profile

Mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up