0370 270 6000

already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

Care Charitable Trust fined after resident suffers fatal fall

3 December 2019

Nazareth Care Charitable Trust which operates a care home in Bonnyrigg, Scotland, recently received a fine after a resident at one of its care homes suffered a fatal injury after falling down a flight of stairs.

On 16 May 2017, 87 year old Shelia Whitehead, a resident at the care home fell down a flight of stairs. She suffered a fractured skull and subdural haemorrhage and later died from her injuries.

The Health and Safety Executive undertook an investigation and found that there was a failure to implement adequate measures to control the risk of residents falling down the stairs. The Health and Safety Executive also found there was a lack of an effective physical barrier by the stairs.

The Trust pleaded guilty to section 33 of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974. Sheriff Thomas Welsh QC imposed a fine of £40,000 for the serious health and safety breach.

The family are disappointed at the low level of the fine imposed and have queried why a charitable trust operating care homes should be held to a different standard to private companies (where a higher fine might be imposed).

Undertaking thorough risk assessments and putting in place effective preventative measures are the best ways for care homes to ensure that health and safety obligations are not breached and, as far as is practicably possible, residents are protected from injuries.

It is recommended that regular internal health and safety assessments are undertaken by the operators of care homes so that the right measures can be put in place to ensure residents safety.

related opinions

Changes to the standard of proof for findings of unlawful killing in inquests

The Supreme Court has considered whether the applicable standard of proof in inquest proceedings should be to the criminal standard (beyond reasonable doubt) or the civil standard (on the balance of probabilities).

View blog

A look ahead to the new Building Safety Regulator planned for 2021

The Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee has just announced a new inquiry to undertake pre-legislative scrutiny of the draft Bill for the Building Safety Regulator (“BSR”). Measures contained in the Bill are likely to come into force in 2021.

View blog

Impact of Covid-19 upon level of fine

Two cases have considered the issue of Covid 19 as part of the sentencing exercise. In the most recent, failures by a principal contractor Modus Workspace, who design and refit refurbishments, led to a £1.1 million fine after an engineer was injured from a fall from a roof.

View blog

Members of academy trusts have fiduciary duties

We are increasingly asked are there any limits on how members can exercise their powers.

View blog

mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up