Community infrastructure levy and the subsidy control regime: What local authorities need to know
Local authorities across England and Wales receive significant sums each year through the community infrastructure levy (CIL) - the charge levied on new development to fund local infrastructure.
Authorities then distribute those funds to a wide range of projects: sports facilities, play areas, open spaces, cultural facilities and much more. However, there is a lack of awareness that distributing funding from CIL to third-party recipients, and providing exemptions to the requirement to make CIL payments, may constitute a subsidy for the purposes of the Subsidy Control Act 2022 (the Act) and many authorities do not appreciate that the subsidy control regime may apply to such awards.
This article explains why CIL payments can, and very often do, fall within the scope of the subsidy control regime, how to assess whether a particular payment constitutes a subsidy, and what steps authorities should take to ensure compliance.
Why local authorities are getting this wrong
It appears to us that there are two key reasons that the subsidy control implications associated with CIL spending are frequently overlooked:
The government guidance on CIL (CIL Guidance) refers to the subsidy control regime as having implications for CIL “because of the ability to grant reliefs and exemptions from the levy charge” and goes on to say that “when a local authority grants reliefs or exemptions under the CIL regulations it must do so in compliance with the Subsidy Control requirements set out in the 2022 Act”. Although the CIL Guidance then goes on to discuss exemptions such as SPEI which have limited application in the case of reliefs and exemptions (but may be relevant to the distribution of CIL funding to support third party projects), it doesn’t cover how CIL is spent. This means that public authorities may be missing the fact that the subsidy control regime under the Act can apply to the distribution of CIL funding.
It may also be that authorities have not fully grasped the impact of the materially wider scope of the subsidy control regime under the Act, as compared to the EU State aid regime, which regulated the award of subsidies in the UK prior to Brexit. Under the EU State aid rules, a measure only gave rise to State aid if it was capable of distorting, or having the potential to distort trade between EU Member States. This meant that genuinely local projects of modest value, serving a purely local community could frequently be dismissed as having no effect on intra-EU trade and were therefore not subject to the regime controlling the award of subsidies at the time. However, the Act requires that the granting authority considers whether a subsidy has, or is capable of having, an impact on trade or investment within the UK, as well as internationally. The statutory guidance has set a low benchmark for a measure having an effect on domestic competition or investment, and therefore this part of the test is likely to be met where the other parts are.
In practical terms, this means that a grant of CIL funding to a sports club, a community facility, an arts organisation, or a charity may well constitute a subsidy under the Act – even if the project is entirely local in character and the recipient has no international presence whatsoever.
A practical illustration
The breadth of the test can be illustrated by considering some of the types of CIL-funded projects that authorities commonly support. We have previously advised on the subsidy control implications of grants for sports and community centres, theatres and arts venues, community cafes, and sports facilities. The provision of financial assistance to these types of activities can give rise to subsidies. However, not all CIL projects will give rise to subsidies – careful consideration of a project-by-project basis is required.
The duty to comply: Routes available to local authorities
Local authorities are under a statutory duty to ensure that any subsidy they award complies with the requirements of the Act. Failure to do so can expose the authority to challenge by interested parties, including competing businesses, with potential for the subsidy to be recovered.
Fortunately, there are several routes available to authorities for managing CIL payments that constitute subsidies, including streamlined routes, the Minimal Financial Assistance rules for small subsidies, and assessments of compliance with the seven subsidy control principles set out within the Act.
Whichever route is used, authorities must also be mindful of their transparency obligations. Subsidy awards must be recorded on a central subsidy control database managed by DBT, except where an exemption applies.
Conclusion
The Subsidy Control Act 2022 has fundamentally changed the legal landscape for CIL spending and exemptions. The much wider reach of the domestic regime, capturing local projects that would never have attracted scrutiny under the old State aid rules, means that local authorities cannot assume that CIL grants are subsidy-free simply because they are modest in value or directed at community benefit. Each payment or exemption granted to a third-party recipient should be assessed against the four-limb test set out in the Act.
Where a subsidy is identified, public authorities have various options for ensuring compliance: streamlined routes for community or arts projects, the MFA rules for smaller grants, and - where those are not available - a principles assessment that the authority itself carries out.
The key to compliantly awarding CIL grant is to build subsidy control analysis into the CIL application and decision-making process from the outset, rather than attempting to address it retrospectively. Grant documents should also include appropriate subsidy control provisions to protect the authority’s position.
Our specialist team of lawyers combines grant and subsidy control experience and regularly advises local authorities on their grant funded programmes including providing subsidy control advice and drafting grant agreements. If you would like advice on how to assess the subsidy control implications of your authority's CIL programme, how to incorporate subsidy control into your grant making process and agreements, or assistance in preparing subsidy control analysis and documentation, please do not hesitate to contact us.
Contact
Angelica Hymers
Principal Associate
angelica.hymers@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)115 976 6092
Discover more
You may be interested in
Community infrastructure levy and the subsidy control regime: What local authorities need to know
Welsh Local Government Association conference: Comments from devolution expert
When is a subsidy decision actually made?
Bristol Airport v Welsh Ministers: A landmark Subsidy Control Act ruling
Government investment in zero emission charging infrastructure: Legal comment
Subsidy control lessons from the New Lottery case
Expert evidence in subsidy control challenges: Tribunal draws a firm line
What lessons does Weis v GMCA have for public authorities delivering regeneration projects?
Innovative housing strategies for councils after ‘asylum hotels’ injunction
Public matters: August 2025
Changes to the subsidy control statutory guidance August 2025: What public authorities need to know
Greater Manchester Combined Authority v developer: Key lessons on subsidy control for local authorities
Subsidy control cases coming into land
Government publishes response to consultation on Subsidy Control Regime
Practical guide to the English Devolution Whitepaper
Refining the UK subsidy control regime consultation
The housing benefit subsidy deficit: Strategies for funding temporary accommodation
The legal and planning hurdles that must be overcome to get Great British Energy generating
Update on local authority owned companies: Part 1 subsidy control
Does the subsidy control regime already need changing for the government to kickstart economic growth?
The transparency regime under the Subsidy Control Act - how it could be improved
Subsidy control guidance update - welcome guidance on 'small subsidies' introduced
Subsidy control: Guide to streamlined routes for universities
Subsidy control - lessons learned in the first year
Review of a subsidy control decision: The Durham Company Ltd v Durham County Council, 27 July 2023
Browne Jacobson advising the Welsh Government on the delivery of significant number of renewable energy projects
Subsidy control lessons to be learnt from Bulb
Public matters - February 2023
Government introduces first Streamlined Subsidy Schemes under new regime
Public matters - January 2023
The Subsidy Control Act 2022. Putting the new regime into practice
Government provides guidance on new Subsidy Control Database and the calculation of their value
The impact of the new Subsidy Control regime on public regeneration projects
Subsidy Control Act 2022: economic queries
In July, the long-awaited statutory guidance on the Subsidy Control Act 2022 (Act) was published in draft form (Draft Guidance). A consultation on the draft guidance has recently ended and the results have not yet been published – it may therefore change before the final version is published.
Economic activity for the purposes of the Subsidy Control Act 2022
When carrying out a mix of activities it can be less clear if it is 'economic'. We look at the impact on local authorities & charities.
The UK’s first domestic subsidy control case
We waited more than a year for it, but the wait is over – we finally have a domestic case on the new subsidy control regime.
Subsidy control webinar - 30 March 2022
In this on-demand session, Alex Kynoch and Angelica Hymers explore the practicalities of complying with the new Subsidy Control Bill, and the impact of illustrative guidance and policy statements recently published by the Government.
Subsidy control regime: new Bill working its way through Parliament
2022 is the year in which the UK’s new post-Brexit subsidy control regime will take effect. The new Subsidy Control Bill will form the backbone of the UK’s new subsidy control regime. The new Bill will replace the EU’s state aid rules, which applied until the end of the Brexit transition period.
New Year, New Subsidy Control Regime Part 2: Schemes, enforcement and transparency under the Subsidy Control Bill
In the first part of this article, we discussed the application of the Subsidy Control Principles. In part 2, we look at how Streamlined Subsidy Schemes will be used to grant certain subsidies more quickly, and at the enforcement and transparency provisions of the Bill.
New Year, New Subsidy Control Regime Part 1: The principles, restrictions and exemptions under the Subsidy Control Bill
The repeal of the State aid rules and their replacement by the regime stemming from the UK-EU Trade and Co-operation Agreement (TCA) in 2021 meant that practitioners and public bodies had to acclimatise to a new, more flexible but less certain approach.