An updated consideration of consent and positions of trust
Consent in abuse claims has long been a controversial and difficult subject to broach. Many organisations have been criticised for raising the issue.
Consent in abuse claims has long been a controversial and difficult subject to broach. Many organisations have been criticised for raising the issue. The CICA for example, has been challenged for its use of this in refusing to make payments to the victims of sexual abuse (see our previous article 'Child sexual abuse and issues of consent in a 21st century world' here).
Helpfully, in most situations, the position is clear. For example in civil claims, the court has made it clear that consent can be vitiated by grooming behaviour prior to a victim turning 16 (JL v Archbishop Michael George Bowen and The Scout Association). Similarly, in criminal cases, the Sexual Offences Act 2003 makes it clear that for certain individuals in a position of trust, such as teachers and carers, the legal age of consent is extended to 18 for those entrusted to them.
It is perhaps then surprising that other individuals in a position of trust, are not similarly regulated by the legislation. Sports coaches are in the news a lot at the moment as one unregulated profession. They may have much more one-to-one interaction with a child than say, their teachers, who are regulated by the 2003 Act.
Given the approach taken by the Civil Courts in similar cases, it is helpful to see that legislation now looks to be amended soon to follow suit. Proposed amendments to the 2003 Act will clarify the relationships in which consent simply cannot be given.
For those defendant organisations facing civil action, it continues to be just as important as ever to take into account the relationships between a victim and their abuser and the behaviour which may have preceded that abuse.
Contact
Laura Broadhead
Senior Associate
laura.broadhead@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)115 908 4818
Related expertise
You may be interested in...
Legal Update - Procurement Act
Procurement Bill: Competitive flexible procedure, how will this work in practice?
Legal Update
CyberCube’s Global Threat Outlook: The evolving threat of cyber operations
Legal Update
A new digital safe space – How does the EU Digital Services Act affect insurers?
Legal Update - Procurement Act
Procurement Bill - Are they still playing ping-pong?
Online Event
Data Shared Insights: Information sharing – why, when, how?
Published Article
InLaw: the start of the EPR convergence journey
Press Release
Browne Jacobson solicitor becomes first in private practice to be awarded Plain Numbers accreditation
Press Release
First independent research focused on transforming EDI practices in UK insurance
Guide
Transforming EDI practices in UK insurance
Press Release
Browne Jacobson collaborates with LGiU on report highlighting “critical” role of local government to hit net zero
Guide
Net Zero and Local Democracy: building and maintaining public support
Opinion
Vicarious liability of amateur sports teams for player on player injuries
Legal Update - Public matters newsletter
Public matters - September 2023
Legal Update
The recent judgment in MacPhail v Allianz Insurance Plc
Opinion
Parental alienation a tool for domestic abuse?
Legal Update
Insurance considerations of RAAC failures - air bubbles belong in chocolate, not concrete!
Legal Update
Making numbers easy - complying with the Customer Understanding objective
Legal Update
“TOBA traps” - general exposure risk under existing TOBAs
Legal Update
The RAAC crisis: Is it really back-to-school this September?
Legal Update - The Word
The Word, September 2023
Legal Update
The Word, August 2023
Legal Update
Work experience placements – commendable: have them, and be alive to the risk
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advise Virgin Money on refinancing of complex care provider Cornerstone Healthcare Group
Opinion
Modern slavery in the care sector – how employers can manage risks
Opinion
£600m funding unveiled to boost social care workforce
Opinion
Are councils failing to tackle anti-social behaviour?
Press Release
Browne Jacobson announces appointment of Barrister to its Cardiff office
Legal Update
PPN 08/23: using standard contracts
Legal Update
Section 117 after-care services – who should pay?
Legal Update
Review of a subsidy control decision: The Durham Company Ltd v Durham County Council, 27 July 2023
Legal Update
London Market Snippets: An eye on what the Insurance market needs to know (Summer 2023)
![Local authorities contracting out enforcement of debts - A review of the High Court’s judgment in Bailiffs Limited v Breckland Council [2023] EWHC 1569](/getattachment/69fe511b-7da4-4d9a-ac5b-f18436ce5fe2/gov-shutterstock_682694722-14.jpg?variant=HeroImageTabletVariantDefinition)
Legal Update
Local authorities contracting out enforcement of debts - A review of the High Court’s judgment in Bailiffs Limited v Breckland Council [2023] EWHC 1569
Legal Update - The Word
The Word, July 2023
Press Release
Browne Jacobson successfully defend vicarious liability claim appeal in connected person foster care case
Press Release - #BeingBrowneJacobson
Building our future town centres: advising local authorities on landmark acquisitions
Opinion
Further consultants strike announced following government pay offer
Published Article
Three peaks of consumer protection: Part two — intolerable harm
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advises Apiary Capital on significant investment in Carbon Underwriting
Legal Update
Advising on alternative treatments for patients – what is the legal test to be applied?
