Reaction: Intellectual Property Enterprise Court judgment finds patent infringement based solely on equivalents
Reaction: Intellectual Property Enterprise Court judgment finds patent infringement based solely on equivalents
The Intellectual Property Enterprise Court has handed down its decision in A Ward Attachments Limited v Fabcon Engineering Limited [2021] EWHC 2145 (IPEC), finding A Ward’s patent to be valid and infringed by Fabcon. National law firm, Browne Jacobson’s patent litigation team successfully represented A Ward. HHJ Melissa Clarke handed down the judgment on 29 July 2021.
The case is notable for a number of reasons. A Ward’s successful infringement claim was unusually run (on the parent patent EP 2 021 268 B1) solely on the basis of the doctrine of equivalents, a concept introduced into English patent law in 2017.
Fabcon’s defence included an ‘estoppel by acquiescence’ argument, based on the historic correspondence between the businesses. The Judge dismissed this defence, and her analysis of the law on acquiescence will be of value to patentees and practitioners alike.
The Browne Jacobson team was headed up by partner and head of the firm’s patent practice, Mark Daniels with senior associate, Nick Smee and associate, Jessica Johnson.
Mark Daniels commented on the outcome: “We are pleased to have assisted our client in achieving a finding of infringement. This case is another example of the courts being willing to find for the patentee on an equivalents basis, where the circumstances merit it. R&D teams conducting freedom to operate reviews would be well advised to explore what it is about the invention that gives the technical expert a “buzz”, and stress test that against what they are proposing to develop.”
New Zealand based A Ward specialises in the provision of multiple loading and unloading solutions to a broad range of industries across the globe including agriculture, chemicals and pharmaceutical, food, minerals, plastics and recycling.
Browne Jacobson’s specialist patent litigation team has a broad range of expertise in enforcement of patents, co-ordination of international patent litigation and dispute resolution, dealing with challenges to the validity of patents, patent entitlement issues, declaratory relief and preliminary injunctions and opinion work.
The judgment can be viewed here.
Contact
Kara Shadbolt
Senior PR & Communication Manager
kara.shadbolt@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)330 045 1111
Related expertise
You may be interested in...
Press Release
Browne Jacobson a ‘discerning choice’ for clients with ‘IP-rich deals and complex litigation’ - as team ranks for both IAM Patent 1000 and IP Stars 2025
Legal Update - IP insights
IP insights: May 2025
Legal Update
Patent litigation strategies in the Unified Patent Court (UPC) and UK
Legal Update
Trade mark strategy in a global market
Legal Update
Advertising trends: Influencers, intellectual property and image rights
Legal Update
Metro’s Runs Afowl of Morley’s Marks in the Court of Appeal
Legal Update - IP insights
IP insights: April 2025
Opinion
What’s in a shape? The impact of 3D registered trade marks on glucose monitoring kits
Published Article
Cloud Computing guide 2024
Legal Update
One to watch: Oatly appeals to the UK Supreme Court in continued fight for its trade mark
Legal Update
Key copyright and AI ruling with broad implications for UK lawyers and beyond
Legal Update
Transformative leadership: In conversation with Lauren Thorpe
Legal Update
Navigating the road ahead: Fate of the UK’s automotive EV market in 2025 and beyond
Legal Update
IP insights: January 2025
Legal Update
UK court clarifies copyright protection for "works of artistic craftsmanship"
Press Release
Intellectual property (IP) predictions for 2025
Legal Update
Alcohol charity on the “Naughty List” for attempts to trade mark “DRY JANUARY”
Legal Update
Considering the growing trends of mindful drinking
Legal Update
Dry January 2025: Legal considerations for manufacturers, hospitality and retailers
Legal Update
The rapid growth of AI in construction
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advises Clean Power Hydrogen on global IP licence agreement
Legal Update
The EU Cyber Resilience Act (CRA)
Legal Update
IP insights: October 2024
Legal Update
CJEU confirms that copyright law is the same for all claimants
Legal Update
Court of Appeal declares that Panasonic’s refusal to grant an interim licence is not FRAND
Legal Update
EasyGroup proceedings defeated by jurisdictional challenge
Legal Update
Insurability by design: Increased transparency for vehicle manufacturers and insurers
Legal Update
ASA bans “misleading” Huel and ZOE ads endorsed by Dragon’s Den Star
Guide
Guidance for manufacturers of EVs and HEVs in the UK: ASA's non-exhaustive electric vehicle advertising guidance
Opinion
New hope for the manufacturing sector?
Guide
EU Artificial Intelligence (AI) Act: Guide for your business
Legal Update
(Deep)fake it till you make it? The ASA's role in regulating false celebrity endorsements
Press Release
Jeanne Kelly recognised in the list of Top 100 people in Irish Tech by the Business Post
Press Release
New resource will support university innovation
Legal Update
A reflection of FIMA Connect 2024
Press Release
Browne Jacobson wins UK Impact Case of the Year at the Managing IP EMEA Awards 2024
Legal Update
Forest Risk Commodities regulations: Steps food businesses should take
Legal Update
Cyber-attacks in UK universities: Why failing to prepare is no longer an option
Press Release
Browne Jacobson Ireland LLP rank across Dispute Resolution, Intellectual Property and Technology in the Legal 500 EMEA 2024
