Why Northern Ireland Courts should have the power to order ADR
Litigation has long been the default mechanism for resolving commercial disputes when negotiations broke down.
However, over the past two decades positive attitudes towards alternative dispute resolution (ADR) have exploded with people, business and governments recognising its value within the commercial space, however, whilst courts in England and Wales now have the power to order parties to engage in ADR, courts in Northern Ireland do not. That gap needs to close.
A changing landscape
The shift in attitude towards ADR has been driven by several factors felt as keenly in Northern Ireland as anywhere else.
Legal professionals increasingly view ADR as a positive practice, routinely recommending it to clients. The costs and delays associated with traditional litigation – exacerbated by a post-COVID backlog – have made ADR an attractive alternative for businesses seeking swift, commercially pragmatic outcomes.
ADR also offers advantages that litigation cannot: it preserves commercial relationships, provides a confidential forum for parties with sensitive information or reputational concerns, and in the case of arbitration – delivers awards enforceable in over 170 states under the New York Convention.
Commercial practitioners in Northern Ireland are well versed in ADR. The culture has shifted. What has not is the legal framework available to the courts.
Position in England and Wales
James Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA Civ 1416, confirmed that courts (in England and Wales) can order parties to engage in ADR, found in the overriding objective CPR 1.4(1), the CPR’s commitment to active case management and the inherent right of the courts to control their own process. Churchill thus confirmed the courts’ active power to order ADR, building on the costs consequences for unreasonable refusal already established in Halsey v Milton Keynes General NHS Trust [2004] EWCA Civ 576.
From 2024 the CPR were amended to codify that power explicitly. Courts in England and Wales can now order ADR as part of case management.
Position in Northern Ireland
The courts of Northern Ireland operate under a separate procedural framework. The Rules of the Court of Judicature (Northern Ireland) 1980, do not confer on the courts an equivalent power to that in the CPR to order ADR.
McStravick (Trustee of the Estate of Denise Montgomery (a Bankrupt)) v Montgomery and others [2026] NICh 1 confirmed that courts in Northern Ireland lack power to compel parties to engage in ADR. Judges in Northern Ireland can only use costs consequences as a persuasive mechanism but this falls short of the more direct intervention now available in England and Wales.
Simpson J’s ruling makes clear that if there is to be an adoption of a Churchill-style model for court-ordered ADR in Northern Ireland this must take place by rule reform.
Conclusion
Whilst courts in England and Wales now have the power to order parties to engage in ADR, courts in Northern Ireland do not. In our view, that position is difficult to justify. The argument for reform is not radical – it is a call for alignment, for Northern Ireland's court procedures to mirror those in England and Wales.
Simpson J makes clear that the court is not against ordered ADR and a gateway remains open: an expansion to Order 1, rule 1A, to allow courts to order ADR rather than merely invite parties to engage in ADR; and/or the introduction of a practice direction drawing on Churchill. The attitude towards ADR has already changed in Northern Ireland. The rules must now follow. For support in assessing your options, speak to our commercial dispute resolution team.
You may be interested in...
Why Northern Ireland Courts should have the power to order ADR
Deprivation of assets and care home fees: Guide for local authorities
Failure to disclose a pattern of fires entitles insurer to avoid charterers
High Court confirms power to order mandatory mediation: Key considerations for litigants in Ireland
Irish High Court issues Practice Direction on mediation and ADR compliance
Impending reforms to civil litigation procedures in Ireland
Navigating PFI expiry and transition: Guide for organisations
No source for concern: IPEC draws a line on software copyright in Edozo v Valos
Court transparency pilot: New public access rules from 1 January 2026
Confidentiality in clinical trials: Arbitration as the preferred route for dispute resolution
Multi-academy trusts (MATs): Unveiling the hidden pitfalls in IT contracts
Ireland’s first Consumer Representative Action issued in the High Court
Browne Jacobson appoints Bernhard Maier as Head of Arbitration
Browne Jacobson expands international disputes offering with new Head of Commercial Dispute Resolution in London
What’s in a shape? The impact of 3D registered trade marks on glucose monitoring kits
The end of the Shareholder Rule: Aabar Holdings SARL v Glencore Plc
Know your dispute resolution clauses: Key take-aways from Kajima v Children’s Ark and Lancashire Schools v Lendlease
New hope for the manufacturing sector?
The Post Office Horizon IT Scandal: How should organisations react when IT systems go wrong?
Changes to the fixed recoverable costs regime
Browne Jacobson Ireland LLP rank across Dispute Resolution, Intellectual Property and Technology in the Legal 500 EMEA 2024
Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil Council: A game changing decision for local authorities
Are amendments to be expected for the Arbitration Act 1996?
How to manage retail sector supply contracts and avoid disputes
Mediation – remote or in person?
Product distribution – how to protect yourself from an early exit
Public matters - January 2023
The Future of Mediation
Covid Rent Arrears: Cinema operators’ appeals dismissed
The Court of Appeal has dismissed two cases regarding rent arrears accrued during the Covid lockdowns. The cases are London Trocadero (2015) LLP v Picturehouse Cinemas Ltd and Bank of New York Mellon (International) Ltd v Cine-UK Ltd.
Safeguarding the incorporation of onerous terms into a contract
Useful guidance on the incorporation of onerous terms and conditions into a contract has been provided by HHJ Davies’ judgment in the recent case of Blu-Sky Solutions Ltd v Be Caring Ltd [2021] EWHC 2619 (Comm).
Litigators beware! Recent changes to Part 36 Offers
Recent changes to HMRC's policy on VAT and contract termination payments
On 2 September HMRC announced a change in its policy on the VAT treatment of compensation and damages payments in the context of early contract termination.
A day in the life of a Commercial Disputes Resolution (CDR) trainee
Ruby O'Hara gives us an insight of her role in the Commercial Disputes Resolution team.
Neocleous and another v Rees [2019] EWHC 2462 (Ch)
Following a dispute over a right of way, the parties’ solicitors agreed in an exchange of emails (constituting a single email chain) to compromise the dispute by the defendant (R) transferring to the claimants (N) a small piece of land adjacent to Lake Windermere.
Stanning v Baldwin and another [2019] EWHC 1350 (Ch)
Issues about prescriptive rights of way and drainage arose on the redevelopment of dominant land.