Predicting the future (and getting it wrong); when a bankrupt’s bad deal can’t be undone
Good news for personal insolvency practitioners, the High Court appears to have closed the door to claims by bankrupts seeking to recover pension contributions made via Income Payments Agreements.
Summary
In some good news for personal insolvency practitioners, the High Court appears to have closed the door to claims by bankrupts seeking to recover pension contributions made via Income Payments Agreements (“IPAs”) following the case of Elston v King & Anor [2020]. Claims of this kind had begun to arise following a period of uncertainty in the pensions arena between 2012 and 2016.
An IPA is a voluntary agreement whereby a bankrupt agrees to make certain payments into his bankruptcy estate for a specified term. This might be appropriate if a bankrupt is thought to receive income beyond his/her reasonable domestic needs. If the bankrupt is of an age when a pension could be drawn this could also be captured. In the absence of an IPA, the insolvency practitioner can apply to court for an Income Payments Order (“IPO”).
Background
In 2012, the High Court case of Raithatha v Williamson held that pension payments which a bankrupt could elect to take at the date of his bankruptcy, but which he had not elected to take, were payments that would constitute “income” for the purposes of an IPO. Permission to appeal in the case was granted, but an appeal never proceeded.
In November 2014 Mr Elston, in compromise of a potential application for an IPO, entered into an IPA which made provision for him to pay to his Trustee in Bankruptcy, sums via various pension plans in his name. Mr Elston was obliged to draw down available lump sums under his pensions as and when they became available to him pursuant to the terms of those plans.
On 17 December 2014 judgment in the case of Horton v Henry (another High Court case) cast doubt on the decision in Raithatha and by deciding uncrystallised pension rights did not constitute “income” for the purposes of an IPO
In April 2016 the Court of Appeal affirmed the decision in Horton v Henry protecting a bankrupt’s pension rights and decided against Raithatha v Williamson.
The Claim
Pursuant to the IPA, Mr Elston made payments of over £48,000 between 2015 and 2017. He applied to recover those payments on the basis that, following the Court of Appeal decision in Horton v Henry, his Trustee had been unjustly enriched because his IPA had been concluded under a mistake of law. He asked for his IPA to be set aside and for the payments he had made to be repaid to him.
Mr Elston’s argument was that, having read the Raithatha case himself (having no funds to take legal advice or oppose an application for an IPO) he believed it was inevitable that his pension would be included as part of an IPO. He agreed to an IPA on that basis.
Decision
The Court held that each party had made an assessment or ‘a prediction’ of the likely outcome had an application to the Court for an IPO been made, and on that basis a compromise in the form of an IPA had been agreed.
The Court gave detailed analysis of why an IPA was a form of contract, and assessed the remedy sought by Mr Elston in this light.
The Court considered that Mr Elston had, in fact, made a mispredicton (as to the way the law might develop) rather than a common mistake of law made between the parties. The claim therefore failed to meet the primary requirement (common mistake) needed to set aside a contract. The application was dismissed.
The Court also held that, as the IPA was a form of compromise, it could not have been avoided for mistake.
Why is this significant?
The decision sends out a clear message to bankrupts to accept the consequences of their actions and suggests that you cannot rely on a misprediction to unpick what turns out to be a bad deal.
This decision could have application beyond the sphere of IPAs and pension liabilities and could be relied upon by counterparties to other types of compromise agreements where there has been a change in the law which, with the benefit of hindsight, would have influenced the way the parties chose to proceed.
We advise insolvency practitioners and individuals in relation to IPAs and IPOs and all other aspects of personal insolvency. Please contact us to find out more.
Related expertise
You may be interested in...
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advises Coniston Capital on private equity backed MBO of FMC
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advise Virgin Money on refinancing of complex care provider Cornerstone Healthcare Group
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advises Thermatic Technical FM on PDS Drainage Solutions acquisition
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advise on Rcapital’s strategic exit from facilities and property services specialist Triosgroup
Legal Update
Banking Transaction Updates - July 2023
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advise Rcapital on acquisition of specialist lift business Temple Lifts from Hitachi, Limited
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advises Apiary Capital on significant investment in Carbon Underwriting
Published Article
The reasons for asset-based lending’s growing acceptance as a preferred funding source
Press Release
Law firm advises on MBO of insolvency and restructuring firm Bridgewood backed by DSW Capital
Press Release
Browne Jacobson celebrate after winning PE Exit award at West Midlands Rainmakers 2023
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advise Cubo on investment to support expansion
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advise on Blazehill Capital’s second £250m facility which will support the UK business market
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advises privacy-first ad tech company Covatic on Series A investment led by Manchester based Praetura Ventures
Press Release
Browne Jacobson announces completion of employee acquisition of Two Twenty
Legal Update
MiCA: The Comprehensive Crypto Regulation Set to revolutionise the EU
Press Release
Browne Jacobson’s North-West banking specialists advise ThinCats on £10m facility to arcade bar operator NQ64
Press Release
Corporate dealmakers advise Apiary Capital on its on tenth investment into ‘Outstanding’ professional education provider
Press Release
Browne Jacobson strengthens its Banking practice with two Birmingham appointments
Press Release
Apiary Capital backed Radiant Financial Group advised by Browne Jacobson on new debt facility to fund growth strategy
Press Release
Browne Jacobson’s banking & finance team describe 2022 as a “game of two halves” after completing over £2 billion worth of transactions
Legal Update
Banking Transaction Updates - January 2023
Press Release
Manchester dealmakers advise Maven Capital Partners on £1m investment in fintech disruptor Nivo Solutions
Legal Update
Sustainable finance - great opportunity but there are risks for businesses that do not engage
Legal Update
Trigger happy when directors’ duties are the target?
In a judgment handed down yesterday the Supreme Court has affirmed that a so called “creditor duty” exists for directors such that in some circumstances company directors are required to act in accordance with, or to consider the interests of creditors. Those circumstances potentially arise when a company is insolvent or where there is a “probability” of an insolvency. We explore below the “trigger” for such a test to apply and its implications.
Opinion
Sequana: Supreme clarification on the duty owed to creditors
The Supreme Court has unanimously dismissed the BTI v Sequana appeal and reviewed the existence, content and engagement of the so-called ‘creditor duty’; being the point at which the interest of creditors is said to intrude upon the decision-making of directors of companies in financial distress.
Legal Update
Banking Transaction Update July 2022 - North West transactions
There are clearly challenging macro-economic factors at play but at Browne Jacobson we continue to see good levels of transactional activity with certain sectors being particularly buoyant: healthcare, financial services, energy & infrastructure and tech.
Legal Update
Banking Transaction Update July 2022 – National transactions
Browne Jacobson continues to see good levels of transactional activity with certain sectors being particularly buoyant: healthcare, financial services, energy & infrastructure and tech.
Press Release
Browne Jacobson’s banking specialists advise HSBC UK Bank plc on management buy-out of UK’s largest family owned bicycle distributor
Browne Jacobson’s banking & finance lawyers have advised HSBC UK Bank plc on the financed management buy-out of Derby-based bicycle supplier and distributor, Moore Large for an undisclosed sum.
Press Release
Browne Jacobson broadens its construction offering with appointment of nuclear and renewable energy specialist
Browne Jacobson has broadened its national construction and engineering offering with the appointment of construction partner Zoe Stollard into its Birmingham office.
Legal Update
Banking Transaction Update February 2022 - North West transactions
Legal Update
Banking Transaction Update February 2022 – National transactions
Press Release
Corporate dealmakers advise on key acquisition of Leeds based fertility health clinic
Press Release
Browne Jacobson’s banking and finance team announce £1bn worth of deal activity and 25% deal volume growth in the last 12 months
Over the last 12 months, the team which is made up of 14 specialist banking lawyers advised on over 300 transactions across various sectors including healthcare, private equity, financial services and tech. The deals have a combined value of £1 billion.
Press Release
Wolverhampton based Slick Stitch secures major contract with high street retail giant
Press Release
Browne Jacobson appoints new head of banking for Manchester to spearhead growth
Browne Jacobson has appointed Graham Ball as the new head of its banking and finance team in Manchester following a period of sustained growth for the firm’s national banking practice.
Legal Update
Banking transaction update - June 2021
What a difference a year makes! See our transaction updates and our confident output in the Banking and Finance team.
Legal Update
UK Community Renewal Fund: prospectus 2021-2022
We explain the UK Community Renewal Fund priorities, submission and assessment of proposals and points to note for authorities.
Press Release
Browne Jacobson advises on set up of credit and working capital funder Blazehill Capital
Legal Update
Banking transaction update - Summer 2020
Legal Update
Deal prospects for 2020: challenges and opportunities
How will the current extraordinary events impact the transactional market? The COVID-19 crisis has certainly created enormous challenges for the deal market.