Milburn Report published to tackle youth unemployment: Legal and HR comments
The long-awaited Milburn Report has been published today, setting out a long-term vision for how the UK will tackle youth unemployment.
Authored by former government minister Alan Milburn, the report’s core focus is to address the nearly one million young people aged 16 to 24 in the UK who are not in education, employment, or training (NEET).
Key recommendations include:
- Welfare reform: Phasing out or restructuring certain disability and health benefits (such as the Universal Credit health element and PIP) for under-25s to redirect funds into active work and training support.
- National insurance: Gradually lowering employer national insurance contributions for under-25s, beginning in the retail and hospitality sectors.
- Guarantees: Introducing a legal "opportunity guarantee" and "support guarantee" to ensure every young person has a path to earn or learn through local Youth Opportunity Services (YOS).
- Education and apprenticeships: Expanding vocational and technical training places and significantly increasing apprenticeship opportunities.
Making social mobility a strategic business priority
Jonathan Tardif, Senior Partner at Browne Jacobson, said: "The Milburn Report shines a light on one of the most pressing challenges facing our country: a generation of young people whose potential is being constrained by barriers to education, employment and opportunity.
"Talent is everywhere, but opportunity is not. The report rightly places employers at the heart of the solution. Creating meaningful routes into work cannot be the responsibility of government or education alone. Businesses have a critical role to play in opening doors, challenging traditional recruitment practices and investing in young people who might otherwise be overlooked.
"At Browne Jacobson, we have seen what is possible when social mobility becomes a strategic business priority rather than simply a corporate responsibility initiative. Through programmes such as FAIRE, we have worked to remove barriers to professional careers and create opportunities for young people who may never previously have considered a future in law.
"But no single employer, however committed, can address this challenge alone. The ambition now must be to turn pockets of good practice into systemic change, with government, education providers and businesses working together to ensure that access to opportunity is not determined by circumstance.
"The true measure of success will not be the number of initiatives launched, but the number of young people whose lives and prospects are genuinely transformed. We must move beyond talking about social mobility to delivering it at scale."
What it means for employers
Emma Hughes, Partner and Head of HR Services at Browne Jacobson, said: “The ambition of the Milburn Report and the direction is right, but there is a central paradox at the heart of it that government must now honestly confront.
“As employment risks increase – enhanced employment protections, greater legal complexity, rising costs – the rational employer response is to become more rigorous, not less.
“More experience required. Stronger references. Only hire the proven. And that is exactly where the Milburn Report runs into difficulty. How does the 19-year-old who has never worked provide that evidence? At precisely the point employers have legitimate reasons to tighten their recruitment, we are asking them to open it up and take a chance.
“At the Westminster Employment Conference, speaker after speaker expressed frustration at the lack of meaningful widespread employer engagement in shaping this agenda. And the employers in the room largely came from large organisations with dedicated talent functions. That is not the typical employer. The SME outside of a major city, without HR, legal support or a talent team is who this policy ultimately needs to work for, and I am not yet convinced the system is designed with them in mind.
“Government deserves credit for the Jobs Guarantee. It changes the proposition from 'please take a chance' to 'we will share the risk'. That is the right model but we now need to apply it across the whole system, joined up with the wider programme of workplace reform.
“It really does take a village to raise a child. The challenge now is to build that village around young people and the employers we need to give them their first chance.”
Emma explores the triangulation between employers, the law and government policy in our latest blog.
Neighbourhood working
James Arrowsmith, Partner in social care at Browne Jacobson, said: “The Milburn Report rightly diagnoses the NEET crisis as the product of multiple, interconnected failures – in health, education and employment support. The answer it points to is exactly the neighbourhood working model the government is already pursuing in health and care, one that creates a single local point of contact through which services wrap flexibly around a person's complex needs, rather than requiring them to navigate a maze of separate front doors.
“But the real opportunity is bigger than service integration. If we are genuinely building neighbourhood systems, we should be thinking not just about how they support wellbeing, but how they build wealth and opportunity too.
“A cold spot in local provision is not just a problem for people needing care – it is a missed opportunity to employ local people, who know their community best, spend locally, and in doing so create more opportunity for others. Wellbeing and economic vitality in a neighbourhood reinforce each other, and a joined-up neighbourhood offer across health, employment, training and education working together is how we break the cycle.
"The question for local leaders in councils, ICBs and combined authorities is whether the work already under way on neighbourhood health and care can be consciously aligned with the system Milburn is proposing. There is a real risk that two streams of ambition, both pointing in the same direction, end up running in parallel rather than converging. The frameworks to begin that alignment already exist. What is needed now is the strategic will to use them together.”
Contact
Dan Robinson
PR & Communications Manager
Dan.Robinson@brownejacobson.com
+44 0330 045 1072