The Milburn Review: It takes a village - but who builds it?
Alan Milburn is right that half measures will not do. The scale of youth inactivity in this country demands something fundamentally different, and the significant ambition of this report is welcomed. My question is not about the offer to young people. It is about the offer to employers, and whether those two things are yet joined up.
Employers are willing but the economics need to work
Employers are not simply unwilling to participate. Research from the London Chamber of Commerce and Industry (LCCCI) found that 61% of employers said they would hire a young person with no employment history if the cost was sustainable, and 58% said removing employer National Insurance for under-25s would help.
As Karim Fatehi, Chief Executive of the LCCCI, put it: "Employers are willing to give young people a chance. What they need is a government that makes hiring affordable and viable."
Yet at the Westminster Employment Conference earlier this year, a consistent frustration among speakers, was the lack of meaningful employer engagement in shaping the agenda.
The ambition is widely shared. The question is whether enthusiasm alone is enough to create genuine, sustained commitment to doing things differently, if the conditions to support that change are not fully in place.
The central paradox
Here is the tension the report has not fully resolved. As the consequences of poor recruitment decisions increase – with enhanced employment protections, greater legal complexity and rising employment costs – the rational employer response is to become more rigorous about selection.
More previous experience, stronger references and longer employment histories. Eventually, employers only hire the proven.
And that is exactly where the Milburn Report runs into difficulty. How does the 19-year-old who has never worked provide that evidence? At precisely the point employers have legitimate reasons to become more rigorous, we are asking them to become more adventurous and increase their risk appetite.
That contradiction needs to be resolved – not by asking employers to lower their standards, but by giving them better ways to assess potential.
Not all employers are equal
There is a further problem the report does not grapple with sufficiently. The employer voices most audible in this debate, including at the Westminster conference, tend to come from large organisations with dedicated talent and early-careers functions, where someone's entire job is focused on this.
A smaller business, a regional charity or an SME outside of a major city does not have that infrastructure. And when you look beyond our urban centres, where the labour market and local economy are structured very differently, that gap is real and significant.
A framework designed around the capacity of a large corporate employer will not automatically work for the smaller, less resourced organisations and especially those outside of our cities.
The Jobs Guarantee shows what resolution can look like
This is where government deserves credit. The expanded Jobs Guarantee – funding wages for more than 90,000 young people, with support before, during and after employment – changes the proposition from "please take a chance on this person" to "we will share the risk and not leave you to navigate this alone".
For employers, this becomes a low-risk way to bring in someone who ends up adding genuine value. That is the right model and it should be the template for the wider system, not a standalone programme.
The missing ingredient is triangulation
Alongside the Milburn agenda, we are talking to the same employers about one of the most significant periods of employment law change in many years. Those organisations may not have HR, L&D, occupational health or in-house employment lawyers.
The management capacity to bring in an inexperienced young person is itself part of the cost. And that cost is rising, not falling. Neil Carberry, Chief Executive of the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD), is right that the risk is decisions made in silos that "leave employers struggling and young people out of work".
Government has shown through the Jobs Guarantee it understands at least part of the risk equation. The challenge now is to apply that thinking across the whole system.
It takes a village
For many young people, an invisible employment village already exists – parents who explain applications, family connections who arrange work experience, someone who encourages them after rejection.
Social disadvantage can mean much less access to that infrastructure. The answer is not to expect an individual employer to become the whole village. It is to build the village around both the young person and the employer – including the smaller employer, the regional employer, the one without a talent team and without the time.
There are already many organisations doing great work in this space. Employers are encouraged to seek them out and find out what programmes and initiatives are already available to help them and their talent.
Government can’t ask employers to carry all the risk, and employers can’t expect government to remove all of it. The objective should be to understand, reduce and share that risk – sufficiently that giving an untested young person their first opportunity becomes a sound business decision as well as the right thing to do.
Contact
Emma Hughes
Partner
emma.hughes@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)330 045 2338