The Milburn Report is out: Here's why employers should read it carefully
Nearly one million young people in the UK aren't in education, employment or training (NEET). That's the crisis the long-awaited Milburn Report is trying to fix.
The report's key proposals include:
- Phasing out or restructuring certain disability and health benefits for under-25s, specifically the Universal Credit health element and Personal Independence Payment, to redirect funding into work and training support.
- Gradually reducing employer national insurance contributions for under-25s, starting in retail and hospitality.
- A legal ‘opportunity guarantee’ and ‘support guarantee’ giving every young person a path to earn or learn through local Youth Opportunity Services.
- A significant expansion of apprenticeships and vocational training places.
The direction of travel is positive. But there's a tension sitting at the heart of this report that employers need to understand before they decide how to respond.
The law is pulling in the opposite direction
The backdrop to the Milburn Report’s proposed reforms is the Employment Rights Act. This brings guaranteed hours, expanded statutory sick pay eligibility and day one unfair dismissal rights. Increased tribunal exposure, along with government policies that have driven up national insurance contributions and national minimum wage, are adding costs.
For a business owner weighing up whether to hire a 19-year-old with no work history, the risk calculus has shifted. Think about it practically: if that hire doesn't work out within the first few months, the legal and financial consequences are now considerably harder to manage than they were two years ago.
The Milburn Report doesn't exactly grapple with this. It asks employers to open up recruitment at precisely the moment the system makes getting it wrong more expensive.
The Jobs Guarantee seems to be the right instinct. Shared risk is a model that can change employer behaviour at scale. But it can't sit in isolation from the wider programme of workplace reform. Those two policy streams need to be joined up deliberately, not left to hope they find each other.
Three things employers should be doing right now
Don't wait for the policy to settle before acting. The businesses that will navigate this well are already:
- Reviewing their probationary and onboarding frameworks in light of the Employment Rights Act.
- Getting clear on what hiring through guarantee schemes actually means for their legal exposure, and what protections they need in place.
- Thinking about whether their current recruitment practices, consciously or not, are screening out exactly the candidates this report is trying to get through the door.
The Milburn Report is right that employers are part of the answer. The question is whether the system around them is built to make that achievable, for all employers, not just the ones that have already been given a seat at the table.
Browne Jacobson advises employers across the public and private sectors on employment law, HR strategy and workforce planning. Get in touch to discuss what the Milburn Report means for your organisation.
Alan Milburn's final report was published in November 2026. This blog is the second in a series focusing on the employment implications of the report's recommendations. For our initial reaction on what the key recommendations mean for employers, social mobility and neighbourhood working, read our legal and HR comments.
Contact
Emma Hughes
Partner
emma.hughes@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)330 045 2338