Nutrition and health claims (NHCRs) in advertising in Autumn 2026
Section 15 of the CAP Code and Section 13 of the BCAP Code reflect the requirements Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 on nutrition and health claims made on foods ('NHCR'), meaning that claims on or about food and drink which relate to health are highly regulated in the UK. Only health claims which are listed as authorised on the Great Britain Nutrition and Health Claims Register ('GB NHC Register') can be made.
In the Autumn 2025 edition we shared a refresher on the NHCRs and covered some key areas where advertisers tripped up. The underlying law is now nearly 20 years old, but recent rulings continue to highlight recurring issues. We have covered the key rulings below.
In summary, this autumn saw advertisers being found in breach of rules on health claims by:
- adapting authorised claim wording in ways the ASA considered went beyond the permitted meaning;
- relying solely on scientific substantiation to substantiate unauthorised claims;
- redacting testimonials which the ASA found still implied disease prevention; and
- using health professional endorsements alongside health claims.
Separately to the rules reflecting the NHCRs, the ASA investigated the social responsibility implications of marketing a food product as a complete replacement for conventional meals.
1. Substantiation doesn’t override authorisation
Generally, to be able to show that a claim is not misleading, advertisers need to evidence their claims. The health claims regime limits claims which can be made to those that have been authorised. To be authorised, the underlying evidence needs to have been assessed by the relevant authority. Advertisers still need to hold evidence to be able to show they meet the criteria of use for an authorised health claim, but if a claim has not been authorised, submitting evidence to the ASA will not be able to override the fact the claim is unauthorised.
The first hurdle is that the nutrient or food referenced in the ad must match the one in the health claim was authorised for. The ASA ruled against claims for pecans which were based on an authorised claim for walnuts and claims for coffee which the advertiser sought to support with an authorised claim for olive oil.
Several advertisers pointed the ASA to scientific evidence which they considered to support the claims their ads made. Whitworths, for example, cited a body of peer-reviewed literature linking nut consumption to improved cardiovascular outcomes and lower all-cause mortality. Exhale referenced independent lab testing from nine different labs to demonstrate high polyphenol and antioxidant content.
However, unless the specific claim, or one with the same meaning for consumers, is authorised on the GB NHC Register and the relevant conditions of use are met, the claim is not permitted. The ASA is unable to assess to the evidence. When the Brexit implementation period ended the GB NHC Register adopted all the previous authorised health claims approved following assessment by the European Foods Safety Authority (EFSA). Since Brexit, there has been a distinct GB route for health claims.
2. Adaptation is potentially possible but cannot exaggerate
The existence of an authorised claim on the GB NHC Register does not give advertisers carte blanche. In the Nutrition Geeks ruling, the advertiser made changes to an authorised claim for creatine which the ASA ruled changed its meaning. While the authorised claim and the claims made in the ad all referred to "muscle strength", the ad’s claims omitted the specific limitations of the authorised wording and was found to exceed the permitted meaning. Claims such as “Creatine fuels the muscle your protein can’t build alone” were considered to go further than “Daily creatine consumption can enhance the effect of resistance training on muscle strength in adults over the age of 55.”
Exhale pointed to an authorised polyphenol claim on the Register, but that claim related only to olive oil polyphenols and their effect on blood lipids, not to the antioxidant or telomere-related benefits promoted in the ad for coffee.
Practical takeaway: Advertisers are best served by starting from the GB NHC Register itself. The first step is to identify the specific authorised claim and its conditions of use, then build the advertising message around that permitted wording, adapting it only within the bounds of flexibility that preserve the same meaning for consumers. Substantiation should then be used to demonstrate that the product meets the conditions of use for the claim in question, such as nutrient thresholds or target populations.
3. Testimonials need careful consideration
The Turmeric Co. sought to use testimonials by blurring specific words within customer testimonials, intending to avoid directly naming medical conditions. However, the ASA considered that the surrounding text (references to symptoms being "halved", "very much reduced", or “no longer requiring treatment") left the overall meaning intact. The ASA found that consumers were effectively invited to fill in the gaps from context. The testimonials therefore implied that the food supplements could prevent, treat or cure human disease, in breach of rules 15.6 and 15.6.2. The accompanying strapline, which told consumers they could "read the lot" on Trustpilot because "regulations mean we can't show everything on this page", only reinforced that impression.
Health claims that refer to the recommendation of an individual health professional cannot be made in food or drink ads. Referring to a testing process being overseen by the company’s Director and Chief Science Officer who carried the title 'Dr' in the context of health claims was ruled to breach 15.6.3 of the CAP Code.
Practical takeaway: First, redacting or obscuring prohibited claims does not render them compliant – if the overall meaning survives the edit, so does the breach. Second, where testimonial content touches on health, advertisers must ensure it does not stray into disease prevention or treatment territory, whether the words come from the brand, a customer or an influencer. Genuine experience is a prerequisite, but it is not a defence to making claims the Code does not permit.
4. Overall impression
The ASA will consider the overall impression given by an ad as well as the literal wording of a claim.
In the most recent ruling against an ad for the food supplement Huel, a podcast ad was ruled to encourage or condone irresponsible dietary habits by suggesting replacing conventional food with the product was nutritionally appropriate. While neither speaker expressly stated that exclusively consuming Huel was beneficial or recommended, the ad referenced an individual who had only eaten Huel and had won an ultramarathon race by a significant lead. The ASA ruled that this was presented in positive light and the overall effect wasn’t cautionary.
The ASA also ruled that the ad made a general health claim. General health claims relating to the beneficial relationship between Huel, endurance and athletic performance. General health claims need to be accompanied by a specific authorised health claim, in the absence of a specific authorised claim, general claims will be ruled in breach of the Codes, which was the case here.
Practical takeaway: Always take a step back to consider the overall impression given by the ad and watch out for any unintended direct or implied claims.
Contact
Katharine Mason
Principal Associate
katharine.mason@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)330 045 1382