0370 270 6000

Evidence of guilt not always required for fair dismissal

21 July 2021

In L v K a teacher was arrested following the discovery of indecent images of children on his home PC. His son, who also had access to the computer, was also arrested but charges against both of them were ultimately dropped. Following an investigation, the teacher was dismissed by the school. The fact that he may have downloaded the images gave rise to a safeguarding concern as well as a risk to the school’s reputation and a breakdown in relationships.

The teacher brought a claim for unfair dismissal, but this was rejected by the Employment Tribunal (ET). A subsequent appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) held that that the dismissal was unfair because the grounds for dismissal (particularly the concerns regarding reputational risk) had not been put to the teacher clearly. However, a recent Court of Session hearing has now concluded that evidence of guilt may not always be required when establishing a fair reason for dismissal. Nor does the employer need to expressly refer to reputational risk during the disciplinary process - particularly if the alleged wrongdoing is such that there is a clear and genuine risk to the employer’s reputation.

This case offers particularly helpful guidance for employers when being faced with employees who are suspected of criminal wrongdoing, albeit care should always be given to ensure allegations are clearly defined and considered on their own merits.

Related opinions

IR35 rules to be scrapped from April 2023

The Chancellor’s recent mini-budget provided a significant announcement for business as it was confirmed that the off-payroll working rules (known as “IR35”) put in place for public and private sector businesses from 2017 and 2021 will be scrapped from April 2023.

View blog

Revoking and reforming EU law

The Government has published the Retained EU Revocation and Reform Bill which, if passed, provides for the revocation of all “EU-derived subordinate legislation” (i.e. UK statutory instruments which were introduced to implement EU law) and retained direct EU legislation on 31 December 2023, unless legislation is specifically introduced to save them.

View blog

Gender equality

Randstad has published a report on gender equality in the workplace based upon survey responses from 6,000 workers within the construction, education, healthcare and technology sectors. Whilst legislation relating to sex discrimination has been around for over 45 years, nearly three quarters of female workers surveyed reported that they had either experienced or witnessed inappropriate behaviour or comments from male colleagues.

View blog

Unfavourable treatment

The Employment Appeal Tribunal’s recent decision in the case of Mr Michael Cowie & Others v Scottish Fire and Rescue Service provides a useful insight into favourable - or unfavourable - treatment in the context of discrimination claims.

View blog

Mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up