Our insurance litigation specialists have recently successfully defended claims brought against two schools for alleged health and safety failings.
Our insurance litigation specialists have recently successfully defended claims brought against two schools for alleged health and safety failings.
As well as learning from those cases, there is a wider point about the importance of high-quality staff compliance training and the evidence you can provide at trial to show staff have an understanding of their health and safety responsibilities.
In this article, Associate Katherine Langley takes us through the cases and highlights some learning points that other schools and trusts should be aware of.
A teacher claimed that she had slipped on a wet floor when returning to her classroom during a parents’ evening. Proceedings were issued against the school (as the occupier of the premises and employer) and the cleaning contractors (who were responsible for mopping the floor and placing wet floor signs).
It was alleged by the claimant that there were insufficient wet floor signs and so the claimant was not provided with knowledge of the risk.
The contract with the cleaners included an indemnity clause which was relied upon. In light of the contractual indemnity we requested that the cleaning company take over conduct of the claim at an early stage in the litigation, but they refused. Their position was that employees of the school might have been responsible for removing the signs and they had not been advised that the parents evening was taking place.
At trial the claimant successfully established liability, albeit with a significant deduction for contributory negligence. This reflected the fact that she was aware that cleaning was taking place and there was signage nearby, although not where she fell. The claim was therefore reduced by 40%.
The court went on to find that there was no negligence on the part of the school and that they had the full benefit of the indemnity clause in the contract with the cleaners. Therefore, the cleaning company were ordered to pay the claimant’s damages and costs, plus the school’s costs of pursuing the indemnity point. Importantly, the school was not ordered to any contribution to damages or costs.
This case demonstrates the value of having a robust indemnity clause in place where services such as cleaning, catering, facilities management or sports teaching are contracted out.
Where services are outsourced to a third party, it is essential that contractors are managed to the extent that you can be confident they are providing a safe and competent service. It is vital that any failures to provide services or adherence to health and safety measures are addressed via the appropriate channels. It is also important to communicate with contractors and to retain a record of that communication.
Equally, if you are overly prescriptive with contractors, this can also lead to liability attaching itself to you too and so a pragmatic approach is required.
In this case it was the cleaner’s responsibility to provide and place the signage and to decide where and when they should be removed. Fortunately, there was evidence of this, and a significant degree of ‘control’ rested with them. Had the situation been different, the school could have been considered liable in relation to the deficiencies in signage.
In another recent case, a teacher brought a claim for compensation for personal injuries sustained from tripping on the school stairs. It was alleged that the metal nosing on the stairs protruded and caused the claimant to catch their foot and trip up the stairs.
During the investigation, it was noted that the claimant had reported the defect some time prior to the accident which resulted in the area being assessed by the school caretaker and the nosing pushed as flat as possible.
A defence was maintained on the premise that although it was accepted there was a very slight protruding edge to the nosing on the stairs (around 3-4mm), this was so insignificant that it was not considered to present a foreseeable risk of injury to those using the staircase. This was particularly so by virtue of its location which was close to the edge of the step rather than the middle, which is where footfall would be expected.
The claim was dismissed at trial with the judge accepting that such a trivial defect could not be considered a reasonably foreseeable source of danger.
As demonstrated in this example, not all accidents that occur in a school setting are as a result of a breach of duty on the part of the school. Unfortunately though, accidents can and will happen and where the accident arises out of a difference in levels or defect in flooring, there must be an element of realism applied when assessing if there is “fault”.
Alongside staff actions and inactions, health and safety training and knowledge often feature in claims for alleged health and safety failings against schools. Being able to evidence staff knowledge through data that shows training outcomes strengthens your defence at trial and goes to evidencing a strong compliance regime in your setting.
To get the best out of compliance training, follow these three basic rules:
EduCompli, our own staff training platform offers health and safety training for all staff that ticks these crucial boxes.
Written by our expert health and safety practitioners, the course is fun and engaging (starting with a myth busting round to get staff in the right mood!) and can be played on multiple devices including phones and tablets which make it more accessible to staff. Importantly, staff outcome reporting – which includes highlighting knowledge gaps – is instantly available so you can evidence staff understanding and plan how to plug those knowledge gaps.
To arrange a complimentary trial of EduCompli please complete the form on this webpage.
Regardless of the outcome of ballots on industrial action, unless there is drastic change to funding for schools in relation to pay increases, it will be unusual to find any organisational budget that is not impacted by the current economic situation.
There’s been little evidence of interventions or financial management reviews this year and it appears the Education and Skills Funding Agency (ESFA) has re-focussed on financial delivery. It’s also telling that there were no discernible changes to the reporting of financial irregularities in the Academies Trust Handbook 2022.
The Children’s Commissioner, Rachel De Souza, has recently published a report “Beyond the labels: a SEND system which works for every child, every time”, which she intends to sit alongside the DfE’s SEND Review (2019) and SEND Green Paper (2022) and which she hopes will put children’s voices at the heart of the government’s review of SEND system.
As well as providing day-to-day support to help you focus on managing your settings, we also provide training and professional development on a range of topics to keep you and your staff up-to-date.
The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHCR) recently issued new, non-statutory guidance regarding the wearing of natural or protective hairstyles, specifically in reference to their representation in uniform, behaviour or standalone appearance policies.
Emma Hughes, head of HR services at Browne Jacobson, explains how CST’s updated executive pay report and the linked benchmarking service from XpertHR can help trust boards make robust decisions on pay.
There’s greater opportunity than ever for parents, carers and guardians to voice any concerns they have relating to their child’s education and for their concerns to be heard and to be taken seriously. While most staff in schools and academies are conscious of their legal duties relating to complaints management, many are struggling to cope with such a significant increase in the volume of complaints they must manage.
This guidance has been prepared to support academy trusts (Trusts) who want to hold a fully virtual Annual General Meeting (AGM) or a hybrid AGM, as we know that Trusts may want to be prepared for future disruption as well as having a general interest in holding more meetings virtually. The guidance also applies to other meetings of the Members (known as General Meetings).
We’re pleased to collaborate with Lloyds Bank, who recently asked us and audit and risk specialists Crowe UK to offer guidance that academy trusts would find helpful when considering setting up a trading subsidiary.
The DfE has published new guidance and opened the application process for window two of the Trust Capacity Fund (TCaF) for 2022/2023, with a fund of £86m in trust capacity funding focused particularly on education investment areas.
The Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse was established in March 2015. We now have its report. As you would expect with such a broad scope, the report is long and makes a number of far-reaching recommendations. In this article, Dai Durbridge highlights seven of the 20 recommendations, sets out how they could impact on schools and suggests what steps to take now.
Browne Jacobson’s education team has been named as winner of the ‘Legal Advisors to Education Institutions’ category at the Education Investor Awards 2022 for a record sixth time.
Since the new Suspensions and Exclusions Statutory Guidance was published, we have received a lot of questions about the use of managed moves. For the first time, the Statutory Guidance does explain what a managed move is, but in relatively broad terms and does not cover the mechanics of how a managed move should operate.
Over 3000 young people from across the UK and Ireland took part in a virtual legal careers insight event, aimed at making the legal profession more diverse.
Holly Quirk, an associate barrister in Browne Jacobson’s Manchester office, was awarded the Legal Professional of the Year Award at this year’s Manchester Young Talent Awards.
The risk of assault against staff is, sadly, something that all schools need to consider carefully. Here one legal expert explains what they can do to protect staff and ensure they fulfil their duty of care.
Two directors of a construction company were fined after failing to ensure the safe removal of asbestos from a plot of land. On 14 and 15 November 2021, Directors Anthony Sumner and Neil Brown, of Waterbarn Limited were involved in the uncontrolled removal of asbestos material from a plot of land in Grasscroft, Oldham.
An engineering company in Tyne and Wear was fined £20,000 after a worker fractured his pelvis and suffered internal injuries after falling through a petrol station forecourt canopy, whilst he was replacing the guttering.
Browne Jacobson’s education team has again been confirmed as a national powerhouse after securing five Tier 1 rankings relating to Education in the latest edition of Legal 500 and maintaining a Band 1 UK-wide ranking for Education in Chambers & Partners UK 2023.
Created at the end of the Brexit transition period, Retained EU Law is a category of domestic law that consists of EU-derived legislation retained in our domestic legal framework by the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018. This was never intended to be a permanent arrangement as parliament promised to deal with retained EU law through the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (the “Bill”).
It is clear that the digital landscape, often termed cyberspace, is a man-made environment, in which human behaviour dominates and where technology both influences and aids our role in it — through the internet, telecoms and networked computer systems, which are often interdependent. The extent to which any organisation is potentially vulnerable to cyber-attack depends on how well these elements are aligned.
In this article we set out the criteria, expectations and support schools should consider if notified they fall within this new category.
The words “Grammar schools” are once again being whispered in government and the question of whether the creation of new grammar schools will finally be implemented as a central focus to DFE policy has re-surfaced.
As a result of a recent Charity Commission legal action, the former trustee of a Welsh charity was ordered to pay over £117,000 to Wrexham charities which support cancer patients.
Academy trusts no longer need to seek consent for contractual indemnities within the ‘normal course of business’. What do trusts need to consider?
In this article we set out the most common issues we encounter, along with guidance on assessing and mitigating the risk from assaults.
In this article we set out some of the support that's available to schools in a bid to reduce the overhead that complaints management generates.
As we start the Autumn term, the first part of the process for changing school admission arrangements can begin.
On 21 September 2022, we had the pleasure of hosting a Whitehall & Industry Group (WIG) lunchtime briefing, delivered by the Director General for the DfE’s Strategy Group, Julia Kinniburgh.
Law firm Browne Jacobson and the University of Nottingham are launching a ground-breaking two and a half year Knowledge Transfer Partnership which aims to develop and embed long-lasting equality, diversity and inclusion (EDI) principles and learnings into the firm’s practices and processes, amongst its key client-bases and the national legal sector.
In an academic environment, there can be pressures to publish, particularly where funding is dependent upon research and reputation. Whilst there can be competition between Higher Education establishments to be the first to publish, there can also be internal conflicts over authorship rights where several individuals have contributed to the work.
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) have announced they will be carrying out a programme of inspections to primary and secondary school establishments from September 2022. The inspections will assess how schools are managing the risks from asbestos and meeting the Duty to Manage requirements, set out in Regulation 4 of the Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012.
In July 2022, the Supreme Court handed down its long-awaited Judgement in the case of Harpur Trust v Brazel relating to the correct calculation of statutory holiday pay for part year workers. This decision has implications for all part year workers on contracts which subsist all year round, whether their hours are normal or irregular.
Universities and colleges are not immune from deception by unscrupulous bad actors. The extent to which educational institutions can manage and control risk not only depends on financial management and internal controls, but also the robustness of security and processes which can be exploited from outside the organisation.
The new set of Legal 500 directory rankings have been published and we are proud to once again be recognised as one of the country’s leading firms advising the Education sector.