Court of Appeal rules on faith school admissions and race discrimination
A single point in an admissions policy can make the difference between a child getting a place and missing out. That was the position in a recent Court of Appeal case involving Twyford Church of England High School, where a family challenged the additional priority given to applicants attending Anglican churches.
The Trust successfully defended its arrangements, but the reasons why matter. School leaders should not assume that permission to use faith-based admissions criteria is a complete answer to discrimination challenges.
What was the case about?
In R (CKT and DGT) v Twyford Church of England Academies Trust, a mother and her son challenged the refusal of a school place and the lawfulness of the admissions arrangements.
The school had 190 places, of which 150 were foundation (Christian) places. Applicants could receive up to 20 points based on their own and their parent or carer’s church attendance. An additional point was available where the family’s main place of worship was a Church of England church, including churches in communion with it.
The family attended an Eritrean Orthodox church. The child received 20 points but could not obtain the additional point. In the relevant year, no applicant with 20 points secured a foundation place. What might look like a small preference on paper was, in practice, decisive.
The family argued that the criterion indirectly discriminated on grounds of race and that the Trust had not complied with its public sector equality duty. The High Court rejected those challenges, and the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeals.
Faith-based criteria are not exempt from race discrimination law
Designated faith schools benefit from an exception to the Equality Act 2010’s prohibition on religious discrimination in admissions. The Court confirmed that this does not extend to race discrimination, even where the alleged disadvantage arises from a religious criterion.
The Court upheld the finding that the additional point particularly disadvantaged the family and others sharing their ethnic origin. Evidence about the different ethnic profiles of Anglican and other Christian congregations was sufficient, even without statistics measuring the criterion’s effect.
For schools, the practical point is that a criterion does not have to mention race to create a racial disadvantage. Nor does a lack of complete data necessarily prevent a claimant establishing that disadvantage.
Why did the trust succeed?
Establishing disadvantage was not the end of the claim. The trust could justify the criterion if it was a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
Preserving the school’s distinctive Anglican ethos was a legitimate aim. The trust provided detailed evidence explaining what that ethos meant in practice, how the school modelled Anglican worship for its other schools and why the admissions arrangements supported that role.
The wider trust arrangements also mattered. Its other schools did not use faith-based oversubscription criteria. The trust had considered diocesan guidance recommending a 50/50 split between foundation and open places, but had deliberately adopted a different approach across its schools.
The Court of Appeal upheld the judge’s assessment. It did not give blanket approval to similar criteria at other schools. The outcome turned on this school’s specific circumstances and the explanation the Trust provided.
What should school leaders take from this?
If you're responsible for admissions, ask whether you could explain your arrangements with the same clarity.
- Look at how your criteria operate in practice. A modest advantage can effectively determine who gets a place when a school is regularly oversubscribed.
- Consider alternatives and the impact on families. Schools do not need to prove their approach is the only option, but there must be a defensible balance between the aim and the disadvantage caused.
- Keep a clear record. Minutes and supporting papers should explain the equality implications considered during admissions policy approval, relevant guidance reviewed and the reasons for the approach adopted.
The public sector equality duty
The Court found the public sector equality duty was satisfied. It emphasised that there is no prescribed form for considering these issues. However, it recognised that having an equality policy is not conclusive evidence of compliance. School leaders and governors or trustees should be able to show how equality considerations informed the actual admissions decision-making.
For non-faith schools, the wider lesson is to look beyond a policy's wording to its practical effects. For faith schools, justified admissions preferences remain lawful, but the evidence and reasoning behind them matter.
Contact
Philip Wood
Partner
philip.wood@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)330 045 2274
You may be interested in
Court of Appeal rules on faith school admissions and race discrimination
Be prepared for the 2026-27 academic year
DfE clarifies Fair Access Protocol compliance: Key points for schools and local authorities
Legal views on the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026
What does the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 mean for admissions?
Special Educational Needs: Practical guidance for schools
Parental complaints guidance for schools: Legal comment
Deleting a pupil from the school admission register: The 20-day rule explained
Be prepared for the 2025-26 school year
Unpacking the new guidelines for alternative provision: Practical steps for education institutions and providers
The rise in schools-based nurseries and the practicalities for growing trusts
Fair Access Protocols for school admissions: Addressing common issues
When can schools refuse admission due to challenging behaviour?
School admission arrangements, applications and requests
Embracing AI in schools: Ensuring accountability, compliance and good governance
When should a school add a pupil to its admissions register?
Comments on the publication of Ofsted’s new school inspection handbook
Transgender pupils and single sex schools
Admissions consultations underway: what do you need to know?
FAQs - converting to academy status
Update on schools admissions
As we start the Autumn term, the first part of the process for changing school admission arrangements can begin.
Browne Jacobson’s market leading Education expertise recognised again in latest Legal 500 rankings
The new set of Legal 500 directory rankings have been published and we are proud to once again be recognised as one of the country’s leading firms advising the Education sector.
A new School Admission Appeals Code for 2022
On 1 October 2022 the School Admissions Appeals Code 2022 (“the Code”) comes into force, replacing the 2012 version and the amendments brought in during the pandemic. The Code will apply to all appeals lodged on or after 1 October 2022.
School Admissions Code 2021 – what you need to know
The School Admissions Code 2021 (“the Code”) was recently published by the Department for Education (DfE) following a consultation exercise in summer 2020. The Code is currently subject to parliamentary approval, but it will be in force from 1 September 2021.
Are you ready for any admission’s appeals that come your way?
School admissions are a highly emotive subject. With education often at the heart of a local community, the process can leave schools open to critique and legal disputes. To ensure where possible, the best outcome for the school and individual preparation is essential.
SEN admissions
A recent judicial review case taken by an academy trust against a local authority has provided some useful guidance for schools when dealing with requests to admit children with EHCPs.