Skip to main content
Share via Share via Share via Copy link

SEND funding: High Court clarifies liability for special school fees

20 November 2026
Amba Griffin-Booth and Harriet Boyle

An invoice alone doesn’t make special school fees payable. The High Court has ruled that section 63(2) of the Children and Families Act 2014 doesn’t require a local authority to pay whatever fees a school demands. The obligation must have a separate legal basis, such as a contract.

Special school fee dispute: What was the case about?

In R (Rushcliffe Specialist Schools (Mickleover) Limited) v Derby City Council [2026] EWHC 2940 (Admin), the dispute concerned 30 pupils at High Grange School, an independent special school. 

Derby City Council funded their placements, and each pupil’s education, health and care plan (EHCP) named the school in section I. An EHCP sets out a child’s special educational needs and the provision required to meet them.

The dispute covered the 2024-2025 and 2025-2026 school years. High Grange sought a uniform annual fee of £113,937 per pupil for 2024-2025 and a 4% uplift, followed by a further 2.5% increase for 2025-2026. The council disputed the increases, paid the undisputed amounts and resisted the school’s claim for the shortfall under section 63(2).

When are school fees “payable”?

Section 63(2) requires the local authority to “pay any fees payable in respect of education or training provided for the child or young person at that school, institution or place in accordance with the EHC plan”.

High Grange argued that issuing invoices made the fees payable because no agreed fee arrangement limited its entitlement. The council argued that liability needed a separate legal basis, such as a contract. A demand for payment wasn’t enough.

Kolinsky J agreed with the council. The ordinary meaning of “payable”, supported by its use elsewhere in education legislation, assumes a separate legal basis for payment. It doesn’t allow a school to decide unilaterally what the authority must pay.

Drawing on Slough Borough Council v Special Educational Needs and Disability Tribunal [2010] EWCA Civ 668, the judge explained that the legislation protects parents from bearing the relevant educational costs. It doesn’t give independent schools a standalone public law route to recover whatever fees they set.

The judge also noted the risk of unequal pricing power where councils have few alternatives. Moving pupils simply because of a fee dispute would sit uneasily with the aim of securing satisfactory provision for children and young people with special educational needs.

EHCP funding: Does the plan cover one-to-one support?

A separate issue concerned Pupil 16, who received one-to-one support. His EHCP referred to individual support available flexibly throughout the school day but didn’t specify one-to-one support.

The school argued that section 63(2) covered the wider “education or training” it provided, not just the provision specified in the EHCP. The judge disagreed: the words “in accordance with the EHC plan” limited the statutory duty.

Pupil 16’s plan didn’t specify one-to-one support. A review meeting that left the plan unchanged couldn’t expand that duty. The judge left open whether any of those fees could be recovered in private law.

SEND funding disputes: What should school leaders do?

The court dismissed the judicial review claim but didn’t decide whether the school could recover the disputed fees under contract, implied terms or restitution. The ruling limits reliance on section 63(2); it doesn’t settle the underlying private law dispute.

For school leaders, business managers and finance teams, the priority is to establish the legal basis for payment. Check that your placement agreements address:

  • The fees payable for each placement.
  • How fee increases are agreed.
  • The basis for charging for additional support.

Where agreements are incomplete, consider whether the parties’ dealings, implied terms, reasonable payment or restitution provide a basis for recovery.

For local authorities, an invoice alone doesn’t establish what is payable under section 63(2). That isn’t a licence to disregard sums legally due. Review commissioning arrangements so that fees and dispute resolution procedures are clear from the outset.

For parents, the judgment reaffirms the protective purpose of section 63(2): the authority, not the family, should bear the relevant educational costs.

If you’re dealing with a special school fee dispute or reviewing placement agreements, contact Amba Griffin-Booth to discuss your next steps.

Browne Jacobson successfully advised Derby City Council in this matter. Amba Griffin-Booth, Principal Associate in our commercial disputes resolution team, led the case, instructed alongside Jonathan Moffett KC.

Contact

Contact

Amba Griffin-Booth

Principal Associate

Amba.Griffin-Booth@brownejacobson.com

+44 (0)330 045 2489

View profile
Can we help you? Contact Amba

Harriett Boyle

Solicitor Apprentice

harriett.boyle@brownejacobson.com

+44 (0)330 045 2497

View Profile
Can we help you? Contact Harriett

You may be interested in...