IR35 and the Issue of Control
The Upper Tribunal (UT) has considered the issue of control in the case of Christa Ackroyd Media Ltd –v- The Commissioners for HMRC and has upheld the decision of the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) that IR35 applied.
01 November 2019
The Upper Tribunal (UT) has considered the issue of control in the case of Christa Ackroyd Media Ltd –v- The Commissioners for HMRC and has upheld the decision of the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) that IR35 applied. The UT agreed that, had Ms Ackroyd’s services been provided directly to the BBC (rather than via her personal services company), the BBC would have had sufficient control over her to amount to a deemed employment relationship.
There was no express clause in the relevant contract dealing with control. The FTT and UT therefore had to consider what the implied terms were. It has been acknowledged in previous cases that there may well be positions which have a high degree of day-to-day autonomy – in such cases, the issue is not whether control is exercised through supervision (or even whether supervision is possible) but rather whether the individual was subject to the employer’s orders and directions. The significance of control is that the employer can direct what an employee does – not necessarily how he or she does it.
In this case, various findings of fact were made by the FTT (upheld by the UT) as to the degree of control exercised by both Ms Ackroyd and the BBC. These included that the BBC could direct which services it wished Ms Ackroyd to provide and could require her attendance at events. It also found that, whilst some matters would be left to Ms Ackroyd’s professional judgment, the BBC could direct what work she did and how she did it. The fact that Ms Ackroyd’s contract did not incorporate the BBC’s Editorial Guidelines was not fatal – in fact, the findings reached showed that it was not necessary for these to be incorporated precisely because the BBC retained control and could therefore require Ms Ackroyd to adhere to these. Similarly, the facts that Ms Ackroyd had no line manager and was not subject to the BBC appraisal system were not sufficient to override the overall findings of control.
This decision, whilst consistent with the previous approaches taken in respect of the issue of control, highlights again the importance of the written contract terms, and the need to consider all factors when assessing control.
With the spotlight remaining on IR35 and the planned shift of responsibility and risk to private sector end users/clients from April 2020, accurately assessing the deemed status of contractors is key.
Next steps
IR35: Verify - find out how we can help >
Contact
Mark Hickson
Head of Business Development
onlineteaminbox@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)370 270 6000
Contact Mark
Related expertise
You may be interested in...
10 July 2025
Legal Update
Significant amendments to the Employment Rights Bill unveiled
09 July 2025
Legal Update
Consultation on the new School Support Staff Negotiating Body
11 September 2025
In Person Event
Mock Employment Tribunal
04 July 2025
Legal Update - Employment Rights Bill
The Employment Rights Bill: Is it here yet?
27 June 2025
Legal Update
A new planning bill for Wales: What will this mean?
25 June 2025
Opinion
Pride Month: A time to review DEI
24 June 2025
Guide
Legal project management: A cornerstone in operational delivery of inquiries
23 June 2025
Legal Update
Analysis: National audit on group-based child sexual exploitation and abuse (June 2025)
19 June 2025
Press Release
Browne Jacobson comments on the government's 10 year infrastructure strategy
19 June 2025
Opinion
Employer redundancy guide: Sourcing alternative employment
18 June 2025
Press Release - Firm news
Browne Jacobson delivers record-breaking growth as strategic vision drives exceptional performance
16 June 2025
Legal Update
DEI in school governance: Key themes and insights
13 June 2025
Opinion
Spending Review: Setting the stage for UK investment
13 June 2025
Guide
Using AI for recruitment: The data issues
12 June 2025
Guide
The socio-economic duty: Shifting mindsets for true social mobility
11 June 2025
Press Release
Spending Review 2025: Browne Jacobson lawyers respond to Chancellor’s announcement
10 June 2025
Legal Update
Trans matters in health for trusts and acute settings: The decision in For Women Scotland
10 June 2025
Press Release
Browne Jacobson’s School Leaders Survey illustrates concerns over financial resilience ahead of spending review
10 June 2025
Legal Update
ESG and sustainability report: Rethinking communication and credibility
10 June 2025
Press Release
Majority of UK organisations remain committed to sustainability and ESG, says new research
30 May 2025
Legal Update - Public matters newsletter
Public matters: May 2025
29 May 2025
Legal Update
Is the standards regime about to undergo a significant overhaul?
29 May 2025
Legal Update
Navigating the streets: The legal landscape of low traffic neighbourhoods
29 May 2025
Legal Update - Planning reform
All change: The implications of planning reform upon regeneration projects
29 May 2025
Legal Update
Supporting local authorities in tackling housing challenges
28 May 2025
Legal Update
Consultation on proposed changes to Estyn inspection regime in Wales
27 May 2025
Published Article
Andrew Walker, Bridget Tatham: The case for better risk management
21 May 2025
Opinion
Disciplinary procedures and mental health: Employer considerations
20 May 2025
Opinion
Supreme Court gender ruling: Ensuring inclusion in the workplace
19 May 2025
Guide
Overview of the European Accessibility Act 2025 in Ireland
19 May 2025
Legal Update
Celebrating diversity and inclusion in the NHS: Equality, Diversity, and Human Rights Week 2025
15 May 2025
Legal Update
Supporting mental wellbeing in the workplace: Practical steps for businesses
13 May 2025
Legal Update
Outsourcing contracts in the age of AI
08 May 2025
Legal Update
A New chapter for families: Reflecting on the first month of the introduction of neonatal care leave
08 May 2025
Press Release
US-UK trade deal: Reaction from Browne Jacobson lawyers
08 May 2025
Legal Update
Trans matters in care: The decision in For Women Scotland
08 May 2025
Legal Update
Trans matters in sport: The decision in For Women Scotland
07 May 2025
Press Release
Browne Jacobson signs strategic partnership with Local Government Information Unit
06 May 2025
Opinion
EHRC releases guidance for employers after Supreme Court ruling on definition of woman
06 May 2025