EdTech and AI product safety certification: What the DfE consultation means for schools, trusts and suppliers
On 10 November 2026, the Department for Education (DfE) launched a consultation on a new certification scheme to assure the safety of education technology (EdTech) and artificial intelligence (AI) products. The consultation runs until 4 February 2027.
Checking the safety, security and data protection compliance of dozens of platforms is a real pressure on school staff. At the same time, ethical suppliers face a slow, fragmented process trying to prove to thousands of separate schools that their tools are safe.
An independent certification scheme is a welcome step forward. Done well, it should give school leaders practical reassurance when buying software and create a clearer path for suppliers. But there are parts of the proposal – particularly around Data Protection Impact Assessments (DPIAs) and the timeline for roll-out – that need a closer look before the rules are set in stone.
What is the DfE proposing?
Rather than certifying every piece of software a school buys, the DfE proposes a risk-based model focused on protecting children from data infringements, harmful content and negative impacts on their cognitive, emotional and mental health.
At launch, the scheme will focus on four priority categories:
- Filtering products used to keep children safe online.
- High-risk data processing EdTech, such as Management Information Systems (MIS), behaviour platforms and safeguarding logging tools.
- Learner-facing generative AI tools, such as AI tutors and student chatbots.
- Learner-facing personalised learning tools that adapt content based on a child's data.
The DfE intends to own the scheme and set the minimum safety criteria, while independent accredited bodies will test and certify products for a fee. Initially, certification will be non-mandatory, backed by an expectation in statutory guidance (such as Keeping children safe in education) that schools should use certified products, though the consultation asks whether new legislation should make it mandatory in the future.
Why the DPIA requirement needs a rethink
In the proposed assessment criteria covering UK GDPR and the Children's Code, the consultation suggests that EdTech suppliers could be required to hold a completed DPIA to pass certification.
That approach misunderstands how data protection law works in practice.
Under Article 35 of the UK GDPR, carrying out a DPIA is the legal responsibility of the data controller. When a school or trust buys an EdTech platform or MIS to use with its pupils, the school or trust is almost always the data controller. The EdTech vendor is usually the data processor, acting on the school's instructions.
Processors aren't legally required to carry out a DPIA for the processing they do on a school's behalf. In fact, a vendor acting as a processor can't properly complete one for a school. A DPIA isn't an abstract test of software sitting on a shelf – it's an assessment of how that software is used in a specific school context, with a specific group of children, alongside local policies and safeguards.
Asking EdTech vendors to produce a DPIA causes two practical problems:
- It puts suppliers in an impossible position: Vendors have to draft a generic, hypothetical document pretending to assess local school risks that aren't theirs to assess or control.
- It creates a compliance trap for schools: Busy school staff are often handed a vendor's pre-filled template DPIA, file it and assume the job is done – without thinking through how their staff and pupils will actually use the tool. As an analogy, you wouldn't take your pupils rock climbing and simply rely on a generic risk assessment written by the climbing centre for somebody else's children – because only you know your pupils, your staff and how you will keep them safe on the day.
What schools and Data Protection Officers (DPOs) need from vendors isn't a finished DPIA. They need open and transparent information about how the product works: what data it collects, where it's stored, whether it's used to train AI models and how it's kept secure. Testing whether vendors provide those clear building blocks would make life much easier for everyone.
Mind the gap: The 18-month wait and staff AI tools
School leaders and vendors also need to keep two practical realities in mind:
- Certification won't happen overnight: Once the consultation closes in February 2027, the scheme will take at least 18 months to set up. Schools won't see certified badges in the market until late 2028 at the earliest, so you still need proportionate processes to vet tools right now.
- Teacher-facing AI is out of scope at launch: The proposals exclude staff-facing generative AI tools not designed for children's data. Yet in practice, teachers regularly paste pupil information into staff AI tools to help draft reports, behaviour plans or social stories. Schools and vendors still have to manage those boundaries themselves.
Have your say before 4 February 2027
Of course, consultations exist to iron out these practical tangles before a scheme is finalised, so there is a real chance here to contribute your thoughts. Most of the questions are optional, so you only need to answer the parts relevant to you:
- Schools, academies and trusts: Share what practical information you need during procurement to feel confident a product is safe and save your team time.
- DPOs and sector bodies: Help the DfE separate a vendor's duty to provide clear product information from a school's responsibility as data controller to assess its own context.
- EdTech and AI suppliers: Give your honest view on how testing and fees can be kept proportionate so smaller, innovative providers aren't priced out.
How we can help
Waiting two years for a certification scheme isn't an option when EdTech and AI tools are in classrooms today.
For schools and trusts, we help you put practical data protection and AI governance in place and build your team's confidence to run proportionate DPIAs through bespoke consultancy, Data Protection and AI governance support packs and our Empower DPO coaching and mentoring service.
We also help EdTech and AI vendors get school-ready with accessible, pragmatic advice tailored to your needs – from sorting out your controller and processor boundaries to preparing clear, transparent data protection packs that give school buyers and DPOs exactly what they need to say yes with confidence.
Contact
Claire Archibald
Legal Director
claire.archibald@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)330 045 1165
Colette Deamer
Principal Associate
colette.deamer@brownejacobson.com
+44 (0)330 045 1401