0370 270 6000

already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

company dividends – possible legal reforms?

1 April 2019

Commercial companies are well-versed in the legal considerations and processes involved in the declaration and payment of dividends to their shareholders – typically going through the required steps once or twice year. However, over recent months there have been signs that wholesale changes to the UK dividend regime might be on the horizon.

The recent Court of Appeal case of BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana SA and others [2019] EWCA Civ 112 (the Sequana case) has been a key talking point for corporate and insolvency lawyers (although at the time of writing it is not clear whether the decision will be appealed). The Sequana case held that it is legally possible for a dividend to be lawful under UK company law and yet also capable of being a transaction defrauding creditors under the Insolvency Act 1986. The Sequana case also gave guidance about how ‘insolvent’ a company must be for the duties of a board of directors to switch from being owed to its shareholders to being owed to its creditors.

The Sequana case seems indicative of an increasing trend of looking outside of Part 23 of the Companies Act 2006 for ways to overturn a previously declared dividend. Historically, unlawful dividend arguments tended to hinge on a company having inadequate distributable reserves or breaching a technical requirement of company law, such as the requirement to prepare (and, in the case of public companies, to file) interim accounts in certain circumstances. Given that the government has also indicated (as part of recent consultations) that it is considering an overhaul of the dividend regime in the near future commentators are suggesting that there perhaps seems to be a direction of travel towards a solvency based dividend regime rather than one based on distributable reserves.

This view has been supported by a recent BEIS Committee publication on "The Future of Audit - Nineteenth Report of Session 2017-19" which also contains some interesting commentary on dividends. This publication states that:

  • Auditors should be prepared to challenge management on their accounting of realised profits and distributable reserves
  • Government and the Financial Reporting Council should urgently produce a clear, simple and prudent definition of what counts as realised profits for the purpose of distributions – and the report supports defining realised profits as realised in cash or near cash
  • Companies should be required to disclose the balance of distributable reserves in their annual accounts and break down profits between realised and unrealised
  • Government should adopt a complementary solvency-based system in which directors must state that dividend payments will not make the company insolvent or create cash flow problems. This would complement a revised capital maintenance regime that the report recommends.

Changes therefore appear to be in the pipeline. Watch this space to see how things develop.

training and events

18Jul

Public sector breakfast club: how property can help you deliver your vision Exeter office

Continued financial pressure means councils need to explore different ways to enable services and projects. Join us as Jennifer Grigg, Senior Associate and Thomas Howard, a partner in our real estate department, look at two key themes; investment and regeneration.

View event

9Oct

Managing procurement risks and challenges Birmingham office

Have you ever received a letter challenging a regulated procurement procedure? Has your authority ever had proceedings issued against it for breach of the Public Contracts Regulations 2015?

View event

focus on...

Upcoming webinars

How to have settlement discussions with an employee

The Acas Code on Settlement Agreements provides limited guidance on how to conduct settlement agreement negotiations with an employee. This webinar, will provide practical advice and tips to help you to have the confidence to prepare for and undertake what can feel like a daunting task and a difficult conversation.

View

Your employees, their future employers and your intellectual property

Innovation and creativity is driven by your people. How do you as a business encourage innovation, capture the relevant IP assets and reward your innovators?

View

Legal updates

Guidance on continuous service in relation to redundancy pay

The Redundancy Payments (Continuity of Employment in Local Government, etc. (Modification) Order 1999. This piece of legislation impacts on employees who are entitled to a redundancy payment in a redundancy situation.

View

Legal updates

Tips for dealing with Litigants in Person

This article provides some tips to bear in mind when dealing with Litigants in Person and a reminder of a number of pieces of guidance, to assist in-house teams in dealing with Litigants in Person in disputes or court/tribunal proceedings.

View

The content on this page is provided for the purposes of general interest and information. It contains only brief summaries of aspects of the subject matter and does not provide comprehensive statements of the law. It does not constitute legal advice and does not provide a substitute for it.

mailing list sign up



Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up