0370 270 6000

already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

the Public Procurement (Miscellaneous Amendments) Regulations 2011

22 September 2011

The Public Procurement (miscellaneous amendments) Regulations 2011

From 1 October 2011, the Public Procurement (Miscellaneous Amendments) Regulations 2011 (the Miscellaneous Amendments Regulations) will amend the Public Contracts Regulations 2006 (the Regulations). The most important of these miscellaneous amendments is that the time limit for commencing legal proceedings now runs for 30 days, but starts from the date a potential claimant knows, or ought to know, that they could bring a claim.

Time limits

As outlined above, the Miscellaneous Amendments Regulations change the time limit for bringing an action in relation to a public procurement exercise to 30 days from the date of knowledge - the date the potential claimant first knew or ought to have known that the grounds for bringing an action had arisen.

The Regulations originally provided for a three month time limit, which a court could extend indefinitely if it considered that there was a good reason for doing so. The European Court of Justice (ECJ) felt that this did not did not provide sufficient certainty and so the Miscellaneous Amendments Regulations seek to bring the Regulations into line with the current case law in particular the decision in the Uniplex case.

At first glance, a reduction from three months with a possible indefinite extension, to 30 days with a possible extension to three months seems onerous for potential claimants. In reality the three-month time limit (and extension) was rarely open to claimants. Although claims were almost always only brought after an award decision, the courts expected proceedings to be issued almost immediately after the decision was communicated, ordinarily within a matter of days. So should a bidder only become aware of grounds for a claim on the date that a contract was awarded to a competitor, they will in effect have a longer period in which to bring a claim as a result of these amendments.

However, under the Miscellaneous Amendments Regulations, the clock will often start ticking much earlier than this, once a bidder spots a potential flaw in the process. As such bidders may be faced with no choice but to issue proceedings whilst a public procurement process is still underway in order to comply with the 30 day time limit. Given that the test setting out whether a court may allow an extension has not changed (i.e. when the court considers there are good reasons to do so) it may be difficult to persuade a court to allow extensions beyond the 30 day limit. Bidders may find themselves deciding whether to continue with a flawed process and attempting to bring a claim if they are unsuccessful or bringing a claim as soon as the issue is apparent.

Time will tell whether courts are going to utilise their power to allow three month extensions as it is difficult to see why allowing bidders to wait until the process is complete would be a good reason once the Miscellaneous Amendments Regulations come into force. If a process runs for longer than three months from date of knowledge then any right of action could fall away unless new and unconnected breaches come to light. Potential claimants may feel it necessary to issue protective proceedings whilst still part way through a public procurement exercise in order to avoid missing the limitation period. Alternatively, courts may prefer to allow extensions in order to limit the numbers of claims being issued. We wait with interest for the approach of the market and the courts.

Other amendments

Promptly requirement

The requirement that proceedings be brought promptly is removed from the Regulations. Given the 30 day time limit, it is arguable that proceedings must still be brought promptly in order to comply, but it is possible that extensions to the limitation period could be granted in circumstances where proceedings have not been brought promptly but the court still feels that an extension is appropriate. The removal of this requirement should mean that claimants always have 30 days to consider claims, whereas claimants may have previously only been allowed a few days in which to issue and serve a claim at the end of a procurement process.

Issuing proceedings and serving the claim form

The Miscellaneous Amendments Regulations change the date at which proceedings are started (for the purposes of limitation periods) to the date that the claim form is issued, rather than the date it is served on any defendants. This alteration will provide a few days grace to claimants, who have to undertake fewer steps to ensure their claim falls within the newly reduced limitation period. This will be particularly important for those claimants who are required to issue part way through a public procurement exercise. The claim form must be served within seven days of the date of issue, meaning that it can be served outside the limitation period.

Communicating award decision notice

Contracting authorities will no longer be required to communicate decision notices to any tenderers whose offers have been definitively excluded. An exclusion will only be classed as definitive if the relevant tenderer has been notified and either:

  • the exclusion has been held to be lawful by the courts, or
  • the maximum permissible time limit for commencing proceedings (three months including the discretionary extension) has expired.

Automatic suspension

The automatic suspension provisions of the Regulations (which previously required a contracting authority not to enter into the relevant contract once the claim form was served) will apply when the contracting authority becomes aware that the claim form has been issued.

Criminal offences

The list of convictions which prevent a contracting authority from entering into a contract with economic operators has been expanded to include offences under the Bribery Act 2010.

training and events

11Dec

Lunchtime learning session on Ocean Outdoor -v- London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham Nottingham office

The Court of Appeal has recently handed down judgment in Ocean Outdoor v London Borough of Hammersmith & Fulham. Join us on our lunchtime learning session about this case.

View event

22Jan

Managing procurement risks and challenges Manchester office

Have you ever received a letter challenging a regulated procurement procedure? Has your authority ever had proceedings issued against it for breach of the Public Contracts Regulations 2015?

View event

focus on...

Care Quality Commission and health & care regulatory update 7 November

Carl May-Smith provides an update on CQC & Competitions & Markets Authority enforcement.

View

Legal updates

ECJ guidance on applying exclusions to potential problem bidders

Rebecca McLean reviews the case of Delta Antrepriză de Construcţii şi Montaj 93 SA v Compania Naţională de Administrare a Infrastructurii Rutiere SA, which highlights the European Court of Justice’s (ECJ’s) recent ruling on the interpretation of Article 57(4) of Directive 2014/24 (the public procurement directive), which provides useful clarification over when contracting authorities can apply exclusions grounds where an economic operator has been in default under a prior public contract.

View

Upcoming webinars

IR35: If it walks like a duck...

In the UK, a great number of organisations engage self-employed IR35 contractors to complete work on their behalf.

View

Legal updates

Social care - October 2019

Welcome to our social care newsletter for October 2019.

View

The content on this page is provided for the purposes of general interest and information. It contains only brief summaries of aspects of the subject matter and does not provide comprehensive statements of the law. It does not constitute legal advice and does not provide a substitute for it.

mailing list sign up



Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up