0370 270 6000

already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

consultation on HSE proposal to extend cost recovery

26 September 2011

Three month consultation launched

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) has launched a three month consultation on proposals to extend the scope of cost recovery from businesses that are found to be in material breach of health and safety laws.

The HSE states in its consultation paper that "it is reasonable that duty holders that are found to be in serious material breach in standards - rather than the taxpayer - should bear the related costs incurred by the regulator in helping them put things right."

A material breach has been defined within the consultation as "when, in the opinion of the inspector, there has been a breach of health and safety law which requires them to make a formal intervention."

Under the proposals the HSE will be under a statutory duty to recover costs from businesses where the HSE has had to formally intervene in writing, such as through an improvement or prohibition notice, due to a material breach. It is proposed that an hourly fee for intervention will apply - £133 per hour - to be used by all staff working on interventions. The estimated average cost for inspection which results in a letter is estimated to be £750 with potential costs of tens of thousands of pounds being envisaged in "extreme" cases.

Although health and safety work is carried out both by the HSE and local authorities, the proposals at present do not place a duty on local authorities to recover its intervention costs. However, this may change depending on what feedback the HSE receives to the consultation paper.

It should be noted that only where there has been a serious material breach will the duty fall on the HSE to recover costs, not where the breach has been a technical non-material one or where it is held that there has not been a breach at all. Any costs beyond the formal intervention, such as if a prosecution follows, will not be affected by the new proposals, with such costs to be recovered through the courts as usual.

The HSE has stated its intention to invoice businesses for their costs and for payment to be made within 30 days. Failure to make payments on time will result in the usual commercial recovery process, including court proceedings to recover costs if necessary. However, in order to assist with cash flow the HSE intends to invoice on a regular basis, rather than one large invoice after an intervention has taken place, but will then refund or credit a business for any fees paid if it is later held that there has not been a serious material breach.

The HSE would deal with any queries and disputes regarding costs to be recovered by setting up a resolution procedure. However, where the dispute is not upheld, the HSE would seek to recover its costs for handling the dispute.

The new proposals will apply to small businesses and new startups, in spite of the three year moratorium on new regulations announced in March 2011, although only in situations where material breaches have put any persons health and safety at risk, including employees.

The consultation is accepting responses up until 14 October 2011, with the new regime intended to come into place on 6 April 2012, subject to successful passage through Parliament.

On a practical point, if costs recovery becomes law, businesses will need to be mindful of their dealings with the HSE on a routine level. A routine inspection/visit could become costly and therefore the way in which routine visits are managed is likely to become a much more involved process on the part of senior managers. The aim will be to avoid a finding of "material" breach which may require more robust representations being made at an early stage. Businesses will also want to be mindful of the investigation process and what is involved on the part of the HSE in order to successfully challenge any costs recovery.

Such a change in approach will need to be carefully thought out with much more emphasis being placed on looking forward to the potential consequences of disclosure of information. Whilst the intention would be to avoid a finding of material breach, the consequence could be to provide evidence of potential breaches of the law.

training and events

4Feb

Insurer Insight event London office

Developed for insurers, this exclusive series of events will provide you with operational and practical insights from across the legal spectrum.

View event

4Mar

Private sector development club Nottingham office

We are pleased to invite you to our next private sector development club. At this session we will guide you through a fictional development scenario – covering site acquisition, resolving title issues, negotiating a development agreement and the role of collateral warranties.

View event

focus on...

Legal updates

State aid in loans to wholly owned subsidiaries

State aid is a key concern for public bodies establishing and funding commercial entities, whether wholly or jointly owned.

View

Upcoming webinars

IR35: top 10 tips

With IR35 changes moving ever closer, this practical session will take you through the changes and give you clear advice on how to get ready.

View

Guides

FAQs for startups

Below are some of the questions we are regularly asked by startups, covering a range of topic areas.

View

Richard Nicholas provides a data protection update

As part of our regular updates for in-house lawyers, Richard takes a look at what has changed in data protection law over the last six months

View

The content on this page is provided for the purposes of general interest and information. It contains only brief summaries of aspects of the subject matter and does not provide comprehensive statements of the law. It does not constitute legal advice and does not provide a substitute for it.

Andy Hopkin

Andrew Hopkin

Partner

mailing list sign up



Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up