0370 270 6000

More pain for directors?

21 June 2010

Directors liability in the twilight zone

In the recent case of Lindsay v OLoughnane it has been held that a director who deliberately lied to a companys customer about the companys financial position was liable to the customer for the tort of deceit and that he could continue to be liable until he corrected the position.

The defendant was a director and principal shareholder of a company offering foreign exchange services. Pursuant to the companys terms of business, customers money was held in a trust account. The defendant director had, for some time, been using client funds for his own purposes. Towards the end of the companys trading, the director started to use funds from one longstanding customer to purchase currency for other customers, in effect using it as a personal bank account. The director then forwarded the claimant customers foreign exchange currency to him when the funds became available. When the claimant asked why there was a delay before he received the funds, the defendant emailed him and falsely said that it had been caused by an error on the part of the companys bank. The claimant made two further trades with the company in September 2008 and unsurprisingly, his money vanished.

The customer brought an action directly against the director on the basis of the tort of deceit and alternatively on the basis that the court should pierce the corporate veil.

The claimants action for deceit was successful. The court held that if the deceit claim had been unsuccessful, it would not have lifted the corporate veil. The measure of damages for the claimants successful claim was the amount lost by the claimant less any recovery from the liquidation of the company.

A claimant must prove four things in order to succeed in an action for deceit:

  • the defendant must have made a representation of fact which could clearly be identified
  • the representation must have been false
  • it must have been made dishonestly
  • the statement must have been intended to be relied upon and was in fact relied upon.

In this case, the judge identified several representations which the claimant had relied upon. All of these representations were implied representations that related to the companys solvency and that it was trading properly and legitimately. The claimants case was successful on the first implied representation, which was made by the defendant personally in email correspondence and arose from the way in which the defendant director accepted the claimants order. This representation continued for so long as the claimant continued to deal with the company and so it was deemed to have been repeated in relation to the September transactions.

The defendant sought to defend the claim on the basis of section 6 of the Statute of Frauds (Amendment) Act 1828 which states that no action may be brought on any representation or assurance relating to the character or creditworthiness of another person, unless the representation or assurance is in writing and signed by the defendant.

It was held that the defendants emails were caught by this section:

"In a modern context, this section will clearly be satisfied if the representation is contained in an email, provided that the email contains a written indication of who is sending the email. It is not enough that it comes from a persons email address without his having "signed" it in the sense of either including an electronic signature or concluding with the words such as "regards" accompanied by the typed name of the sender of the email".

Crucially, if the defendants lies to the claimant had been made in the course of telephone conversations or meetings, with nothing then put in writing by him, the claimants action for deceit would have failed.

This decision follows the decision of the Court of Appeal in Contex Drouzhbar Limited v Wiseman [2007] and again highlights the implications for directors who are acting in the twilight zone between a companys financial difficulty and its possible insolvency. A representation made to creditors some months ago, on which they continue to rely, could still give rise to personal liability, unless the person who made the representation corrects it. If directors have given assurances of solvency where this is no longer the case, they should ensure that further communications are sent to creditors to advise them on the change in the position.

Focus on...

Blogs

IR35 rules to be scrapped from April 2023

The Chancellor’s recent mini-budget provided a significant announcement for business as it was confirmed that the off-payroll working rules (known as “IR35”) put in place for public and private sector businesses from 2017 and 2021 will be scrapped from April 2023.

View

Press releases

Browne Jacobson announces 10 to its 2022 trainee solicitor scheme

Browne Jacobson has welcomed 10 future lawyers to its trainee scheme for 2022 – 2024 as it continues to grow its business.
The new recruits have joined 36 trainees currently at the firm, bringing the total number of trainee solicitors at Browne Jacobson to 46 – a record number for the firm.

View

Press releases

Browne Jacobson’s Private Equity specialists advise Palatine on key CTS exit

Browne Jacobson’s national private equity (PE) lawyers have advised leading mid-market PE investment firm, Palatine Private Equity (Palatine) on its exit from CTS Group, the fast-growing specialist in testing, inspection and geoengineering consulting services to the construction and infrastructure sectors.

View

Blogs

Cameras in convenience stores: a potential hornet’s nest..?

A convenience retailer has opted to install cameras (the “Facewatch” system) at a limited number of its English stores to reduce crime and protect its staff.

View

The content on this page is provided for the purposes of general interest and information. It contains only brief summaries of aspects of the subject matter and does not provide comprehensive statements of the law. It does not constitute legal advice and does not provide a substitute for it.

Mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up