0370 270 6000

already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

confidentiality is not an automatic defence to disclosure

13 November 2018

Even documents containing confidential information can become disclosable in a procurement challenge.

In the case of Marston Holdings Ltd v Ministry of Justice (2018), the issue was whether disclosure of a successful party’s tender documents from a procurement process was necessary. The claimant, an unsuccessful party in the process, applied for disclosure of a successful party’s submitted documents.

In a successful challenge, the claimant had an arguable case based on the fact that it had been awarded the top quality mark in relation to the proposed contracts, but was not successful. The argument therefore at least raised the prospect of an issue that the court had to look at.

As long as any confidential information is not misused and is used solely for the purpose of resolving the issues in a case, documents containing such information will be disclosable. The terms of the confidentiality rings already in place in this case were considered to provide adequate protection.

Documents are not automatically privileged on the basis that they contain confidential information. If the information could be used to resolve the issues in a case, the court may order disclosure of the documents. It is advisable to implement confidentiality rings in order to protect such information, or ensure that it will be privileged by other means in order to avoid an order for disclosure.

related opinions

As Japan becomes 'adequate' for data protection laws...will the UK soon become 'inadequate'?

On 23 January 2019, the European Commission and the Personal Information Commission of Japan, concluded a two-year-long dialogue and the adoption of the decisions recognising each other’s personal data protection systems as ‘equivalent’.

View blog

Court of Appeal rules that an appeal submitted out of time should be allowed to be heard

Court of Appeal ('CA') has recently permitted an application for an extension of time to submit an appeal with the Employment Appeal Tribunal ('EAT') because it was in the interests of justice to do so.

View blog

Google penalised €50m for GDPR breach

The first major financial penalty of €50m (£44m) has been imposed on Google LLC (EU HQ in Ireland) by CNIL, the French data regulator.

View blog

Workforce and immigration update - settlement fees scrapped and new settlement scheme

Many NHS Trusts have been debating the extent to which settlement fees should be paid to employees and family members. For those still engaged in the debate Theresa May’s announcement on 21 January 2019 that the settlement application fee would be scrapped will have been welcome news.

View blog

mailing list sign up



Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up