0370 270 6000

Patent litigation - approach summary judgment / strike out with caution

15 May 2015

Swift resolution of patent disputes is key to minimising significant unnecessary costs and uncertainty. However, it is rare that patent infringement proceedings are suitable for summary judgment or strike out.

So it was proved in a recent case before the English High Court. Unwired Planet sued a number of telecommunications equipment providers, including Huawei and Samsung, for patent infringement based partly on some of its claimed standard essential patents. Typically, there had been various licence negotiations between the parties. These negotiations formed part of the dispute, to the extent that the parties were unable to agree whether the licence terms offered by Unwired Planet are FRAND (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) as required by the standard setting body (ETSI).

Huawei sought summary judgment (alternatively strike out) on the question of whether Unwired Planet’s licence proposals were FRAND. Refusing to deal with this issue on a summary basis, or to strike out Unwired Planet’s application for a declaration that its offers were FRAND, the court found that this was a matter suitable for trial – it required an understanding of the complex factual matrix and also a consideration of the parallel role played by competition law.

The trial of this ‘non-technical’ part of the claim is not due to take place until October 2016. This, only after five technical trials (one for each patent) have taken place, commencing in October 2015.

Though it is a welcomed step that these proceedings have been docketed to a single judge, one wonders whether a prioritisation of the non-technical trial might have assisted the parties in settling the dispute at the earliest possible stage.

Related opinions

IR35 rules to be scrapped from April 2023

The Chancellor’s recent mini-budget provided a significant announcement for business as it was confirmed that the off-payroll working rules (known as “IR35”) put in place for public and private sector businesses from 2017 and 2021 will be scrapped from April 2023.

View blog

Cameras in convenience stores: a potential hornet’s nest..?

A convenience retailer has opted to install cameras (the “Facewatch” system) at a limited number of its English stores to reduce crime and protect its staff.

View blog

Covid Rent Arrears: Cinema operators’ appeals dismissed

The Court of Appeal has dismissed two cases regarding rent arrears accrued during the Covid lockdowns. The cases are London Trocadero (2015) LLP v Picturehouse Cinemas Ltd and Bank of New York Mellon (International) Ltd v Cine-UK Ltd.

View blog

80% hours for 100% pay? That’ll do nicely

As has been widely reported this week, some 3,000 UK workers are taking part in a six month trial to assess the viability of a four-day working week without any reduction in their normal pay.

View blog

Mark Daniels

Mark Daniels

Partner and Head of Business Services

View profile

Mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up