0370 270 6000

When can you offset costs against damages?

7 October 2014

In the case of Mploy Group Ltd v Denso Manufacturing UK Ltd (2014) Eder J allowed a stay of execution where the judgment creditor (M) was unable to confirm whether the terms of it’s after the event insurance policy would cover the costs it had been ordered to pay to D. The terms of the policy would not allow M to reveal whether the costs would in fact be paid. M had been awarded judgment in the case but ordered to pay D’s costs. Unfortunately, M had entered into a Company Voluntary Arrangement and D was clearly concerned that the costs would not be paid and applied for a stay of execution under CPR r.40.8A.

The stay was granted despite M arguing that there were no special circumstances as they had continued to trade, and were entitled to the damages awarded to them under the judgment and the ATE policy covered costs.

Eder J held that the main consideration when granting the stay was that the costs payable by M far outweighed the judgment debt payable by D.

Defendants should be wary when about to hand over damages and should think tactically about costs and whether a similar course of action may be appropriate.

Related opinions

The Future of Mediation

In an effort to build a stronger justice system, a shift in priorities has emerged away from adversarial court battles and more towards opportunities for consensual resolution. As one of the most popular forms of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), mediation has become increasingly encouraged.

View blog

Procurement Bill — what’s new in 2022?

The Procurement Bill (the Bill) has now been with us for about four months, during which time there have been a huge number of amendments proposed in the House of Lords (circa 320). Lately, there has been less mention of it — unsurprising, really, given everything else going on in politics recently — but here’s a summary of some of the key issues and themes so far.

View blog

Sequana: Supreme clarification on the duty owed to creditors

The Supreme Court has unanimously dismissed the BTI v Sequana appeal and reviewed the existence, content and engagement of the so-called ‘creditor duty’; being the point at which the interest of creditors is said to intrude upon the decision-making of directors of companies in financial distress.

View blog

IR35 rules to be scrapped from April 2023

The Chancellor’s recent mini-budget provided a significant announcement for business as it was confirmed that the off-payroll working rules (known as “IR35”) put in place for public and private sector businesses from 2017 and 2021 will be scrapped from April 2023.

View blog

Mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up