0370 270 6000

already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

legal professional privilege v iniquity exception… who wins?

14 August 2014

In JSC BTA Bank v Ablyazov & Others the Commercial Court held that a litigant’s strategy of concealment/deceit defeated any claim to privilege it may otherwise have over communications with its lawyers.

JSC sought disclosure of a number of documents held by the defendants’ former solicitors (who were each respondent to the application) that JSC considered these documents showed it had been defrauded of $4billion of judgments.

JSC’s application was made on the grounds that the defendants had pursued a strategy of lying/misleading the court as to the extent and nature of their assets; dealing with assets in breach of Orders; lying/misleading the court as to those transactions; and purposefully putting assets beyond the reach of JSC. JSC also alleged that each firm of solicitors had been used to further that strategy.

In hearing this application Popplewell J held that if iniquity put legal advice outside the scope of a professional engagement or rendered it an abuse of the professional relationship, communications relating to that iniquity could not attract legal professional privilege; demonstrating that privilege cannot be used as a shield against immoral and unjust behaviour.

related opinions

Directors who fail to prepare, should prepare to fail

Two recent judgments demonstrate the risk that directors (of insolvent companies) face of being personally liable if appropriate records and procedures are not followed and if it cannot be shown that certain payments were in the interests of the company.

View blog

Remote mediation – here to stay?

Mediation has long been considered an effective method of alternative dispute resolution. With ‘in-person’ mediations no longer possible, remote or online mediations have risen to the fore.

View blog

Impact of Covid-19 upon level of fine

Two cases have considered the issue of Covid 19 as part of the sentencing exercise. In the most recent, failures by a principal contractor Modus Workspace, who design and refit refurbishments, led to a £1.1 million fine after an engineer was injured from a fall from a roof.

View blog

Important opportunity to comment on case law precedent

The UK government is considering extending this power to depart from retained EU case law to additional lower courts and tribunals, namely the Court of Appeal in England and Wales and the High Court of Justice in England and Wales and their equivalents.

View blog

mailing list sign up



Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up