0370 270 6000

already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

courts consider all circumstances in applications for relief from sanctions

23 April 2014

Post Jackson the courts have taken a strict approach to failure to comply with rules, practice directions and orders. However, the case of Chartwell Estate Agents Limited the Court of Appeal reminded us that under the revised CPR r.3.9, courts are to consider all circumstances of a case when considering applications for relief from sanctions and not just those set out in the rules.

In this case both parties failed to serve witness statements by the date ordered. The claimant applied for permission from the court (pursuant to CPR 32.10) to serve statements out of time as witness evidence was fundamental to it being able to prove its case.

At first instance, despite finding that there had been no good reason for its non-compliance, the judge allowed the claimant’s application on the grounds that refusal would have had the disproportionate consequence of effectively ending the claim. The Court of Appeal up held this decision emphasising that the factors specified in r.3.9 did not prevail over all other circumstances.

related opinions

Can an application to postpone a hearing be refused?

This case highlights the importance of Claimants obtaining their own medical evidence in such matters especially when it is pivotal to their claim.

View blog

A landlord’s promise, a tenant’s power

When it comes to leases, most people believe that landlords hold most of the power. However, in relation to long residential leases, the tables may well have recently turned in one respect at least following a recent Supreme Court decision.

View blog

High Court extends employer’s duty of care to Dubai whistleblower

Employers with global networks which include a base in the UK should be aware that they can face expensive and damaging negligence claims from employees who are based overseas regardless of the whistleblowing regime.

View blog

A year on: the Capped Costs Pilot Scheme

On 14 January 2019 a Capped Costs Pilot Scheme was introduced in the Leeds and Manchester Business and Property Courts, and has been set to run for two years.

View blog

mailing list sign up



Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up