0370 270 6000

Proportionality defence to possession claims? High Court maintains high threshold

26 March 2013

In the recent case of Birmingham City Council v Beech the tenant’s daughter and husband moved into the property to help care for the tenant.  When the tenant moved into a care home she signed a Notice to Quit.  The defence to the subsequent possession claim included a pleading that the eviction was a disproportionate infringement of Article 8 rights, since the property had been their home for a number of years.

The High Court reiterated that the threshold for establishing an arguable case that a local housing authority is acting disproportionately when seeking possession of public sector accommodation is a high one, and would only be met in a small proportion of cases. The proportionality defence in this case “did not even cross the high threshold of being seriously arguable”.

This case highlights the Appeal Court’s robust approach in dealing with proportionality defences. For the right type of case it is worth considering an appeal if a tenant’s proportionality defence is successful in the first instance.

Related opinions

Watch this space on breach of contract, vicarious liability and assumption of responsibility

The concept of Assumption of Responsibility is on many stakeholders’ minds at the moment following the Supreme Court decision in CN & GN v Poole.

View blog

Landlord and tenant inspections - getting the evidence right

In Rogerson v Bolsover District Council (2019) the Court of Appeal found against a local authority landlord pursuant to the Defective Premises Act 1972 following a finding of an inadequate inspection regime.

View blog

Organisations owe no duty to staff when responding to claims

In Bowen v Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis, the Supreme Court have confirmed that members of the workforce aggrieved by the way in which such claims are defended or settled are not entitled to pursue a claim against their employers on this basis.

View blog

Children Act 1989 – Section 20 and consent

The Supreme Court decision in Williams and another v Borough of Hackney [2018] UKSC 37 was an example of the local authority getting Section 20 of the Children Act 1989 right.

View blog

Mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up