0370 270 6000

already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

no enforced filtering of internet use for ISPs, ECJ rules

20 November 2011

The ECJ has ruled that courts of member states cannot force ISPs into broad filtering and monitoring of their user’s access to copyright-infringing file-sharing websites.

It follows an order by a Belgian court that an ISP (Scarlet) must implement a filtering system to block their user’s ability to send and receive files containing musical works using file-sharing software without the copyright-holders permission.

The ruling does not prevent the blocking of specific illegal file-sharing sites by ISPs as in BT and Newzbin’s case; however the ECJ ruled the filter system ordered in this case, in which the ISP was expected to install the system at its own expense and use it for an unlimited period to indiscriminately monitor all customer’s electronic communications, was contrary to EU law and fundamental rights, including the E-Commerce Directive.

This ruling will be welcomed by both ISPs and campaigners for internet freedom, particularly those following the relationship between the E-Commerce Directive and the Digital Economy Act.

related opinions

Sky’s overly broad trade marks narrowed as found partially invalid for bad faith

Lord Justice Arnold has applied the guidance of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) to the evidence before him, in the long standing trade mark dispute between Sky and Skykick.

View blog

Cyber risks – are businesses really ready?

The Hiscox Cyber Readiness report, a review of 3300 organisations, will be a stark warning for CEO’s of SME’s in the UK and in Europe.

View blog

Wearable security

How secure is your fitness tracker? (Not to mention your smartwatch, sleep tracker, smart shoe insoles and wearable Bluetooth keyboard). It’s something that many of us give little thought to, but perhaps we should be more concerned.

View blog

Trade mark owners must reimburse internet service providers for the cost of implementing internet blocking orders

The Supreme Court handed down judgment in the long-running Cartier dispute of 13 June 2018, overruling the Court of Appeal

View blog

mailing list sign up



Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up