0370 270 6000

This software's faulty - what can I get from the seller?

11 March 2010

It’s a query often raised by clients. A recent case has highlighted that it might well be more than previously thought.

Traditionally a party suing for breach of contract can expect to recover losses that result directly from a breach, but not losses that are “indirect” – as these are considered too remote or unforseeable. Typically a supplier will exclude indirect losses and will also exclude losses such as loss of profits, loss of revenue and similar losses. In a recent case however there was an interesting decision as to what a supplier could claim, even where indirect losses and loss of revenue is excluded. This included:

  • Increased payments to suppliers, as a result of using the faulty software
  • Additional costs of borrowing, made necessary by the increased payments to suppliers;
  • The cost of chasing debts that were not due (but which the faulty software suggested were due);
  • The cost of ex-gratia payments made to customers to compensate for poor service – (i.e. payments that the customer was not obliged to, but chose to pay to protect its reputation); and
  • Even the cost of stationery used to write to its customers to explain the problems caused by the faulty software

None were excluded by the typical “loss of profits” exclusion, nor by excluding indirect losses. For software suppliers it’s a potential wake up call that errors and delays in projects can lead to eye-watering amounts of damages – something that it is worth taking the time to protect against when working through the small print of their agreements.

Related opinions

Guidance to help SMEs bidding for government contracts

The cabinet office has produced a very useful guide to help SMEs considering bidding for government contracts.

View blog

Artificial intelligence in legal and contracting

With its claims to disrupt and transform many areas of our lives, AI is now part of our day to day vocabulary.

View blog

Brexit frustration

Are you frustrated by Brexit? If so, that’s more than can be said of the European Medicines Agency’s (EMA) £13m a year lease at Canary Wharf.

View blog

Transformative health-tech in 2018

Last week, the annual Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas showcased some emerging consumer technologies - from a sensor which tests food for peanuts to air-bags for your hip.

View blog

Richard Nicholas

Richard Nicholas

Partner and Responsible for In House Lawyers

View profile

Mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up