already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

repayment of sums paid in advance following exercise of break clause

2 December 2015

The Supreme Court has today unanimously upheld the Court of Appeal decision that where a tenant exercises a right to break a lease, no term should generally be implied that the landlord must reimburse that tenant for sums paid in advance which relate to any period after the break date.

In this case, the tenant had four leases, each with identical break rights on 24 January 2012. Operation of the break clauses was conditional (amongst other things) on there being no arrears of basic rent on the break date.

As required by case law, the tenant paid the full quarter’s rents due on 25 December 2011 and successfully exercised the break rights. However, today’s ruling means that it cannot claim reimbursement of nearly £1m paid in advance covering the period from the break date up to the next quarter day.

It therefore remains imperative when negotiating a break clause in a lease to ensure that the lease contains an express clause obliging the landlord to reimburse such advance payments.

related opinions

Sainsbury’s response to Amazon’s entry into the grocery business

Hot on the heels of yesterday’s news of Amazon’s acquisition of Whole Food, Sainsbury’s look to expand with a proposed acquisition of Nisa.

View blog

Amazon sets the supermarkets in its sights!

Well, I think we all knew this was coming. It felt like only a matter of time before Amazon decided to focus its sights on the grocery business.

View blog

Liability for business rates whilst property being refurbished

With the current publicity over the rating revaluation coming in next month alongside proposed changes to the appeals process, today’s Supreme Court decision will come as a relief to embattled ratepayers.

View blog

Is your lease fit for purpose? Technology and the gamification of retail space

Physical retail spaces are not just 'shops' anymore; barely 46% of consumers felt stores were useful for comparing products. Instead, browsing in a physical store is just one part of an overall consumer experience.

View blog