0370 270 6000

Court delivers food for thought over lease renewals

6 June 2014

Iceland Foods v Castlebrook Holdings Ltd [2014] neatly illustratesthe balance which the court must strike when deciding on the terms of a renewal lease.

Iceland occupied the premises under a long lease. Upon expiry Iceland sought a renewal lease for a term of 5 years (Iceland wanted to maintain flexibility in, what were then, volatile market conditions).  The landlord wanted a new lease with a 15 year term on the basis that this was standard length in the supermarket sector – and the fact that a shorter term would adversely affect the value of the landlord’s reversionary interest in the premises.

The Court decided that an appropriate lease term would be 10 years – a half-way house between what the tenant and landlord wanted.

Whilst this is certainly not new law, the case provides a reminder that whilst the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 is, in part, designed to protect business tenants the court will not simply grant the lease term sought by the tenant; instead in exercising its discretion the court must weigh up the interests of both parties, ensuring that it protects the tenant’s business but remaining fair to the landlord.

Related opinions

Covid-19 rent arrears – the questions that remain

The Government appears set to announce plans on ‘living with Covid to restore freedom’. With the success of the retail and hospitality sector key to recovery, what protections will be on offer to tenants to deal with Covid-19 rent arrears?

View blog

Handing back an empty shell of a building did not prevent a tenant from exercising a break clause

Break rights have proved a fertile source of litigation over the last few years. More often than not, tenants have found themselves on the wrong end of the decisions. However, a Court of Appeal decision yesterday has bucked that trend.

View blog

Relief for landlords as the Court of Appeal confirms that leases have been validly contracted out

One of the requirements for tenants to contract out of the security of tenure regime contained in the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 is that they make a simple or statutory declaration before entering into the lease.

View blog

Summary judgment stayed where part 26A restructuring plan pending

Landlords should reconsider summary judgment if a Part 26A restructuring plan is pending.

View blog

Mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up