0370 270 6000

The right to criticise?

5 September 2012

Optical Express has failed to get the domain name opticalexpressruinedmylife.co.uk transferred to it.

The Nominet Expert decided that the domain name was a genuine criticism website; so although Optical Express was found to have relevant rights in a name or mark similar to the domain name, it could not be characterised as an “Abusive Registration”.

This is in contrast to a previous decision in which ihateryanair.co.uk was ordered to be transferred to Ryanair. In that case, receiving advertising revenue from the site was sufficient to render the registration abusive.

The Expert in opticalexpressruinedmylife.co.uk suggested this approach could be “somewhat harsh” but in any event, the registrant of opticalexpressruinedmylife.co.uk had not sought to profit from the domain.

This decision emphasises that the right to criticise is important to free speech and shows that brand owners may not be able to use the Nominet DRS to shut down genuine criticism sites, although there will still be routes available in the courts to prevent defamation or Trade Mark infringement.

Related opinions

Covid-19 rent arrears – the questions that remain

The Government appears set to announce plans on ‘living with Covid to restore freedom’. With the success of the retail and hospitality sector key to recovery, what protections will be on offer to tenants to deal with Covid-19 rent arrears?

View blog

Handing back an empty shell of a building did not prevent a tenant from exercising a break clause

Break rights have proved a fertile source of litigation over the last few years. More often than not, tenants have found themselves on the wrong end of the decisions. However, a Court of Appeal decision yesterday has bucked that trend.

View blog

Relief for landlords as the Court of Appeal confirms that leases have been validly contracted out

One of the requirements for tenants to contract out of the security of tenure regime contained in the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 is that they make a simple or statutory declaration before entering into the lease.

View blog

Summary judgment stayed where part 26A restructuring plan pending

Landlords should reconsider summary judgment if a Part 26A restructuring plan is pending.

View blog

Mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up