0370 270 6000

already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

patient confidentiality erosion? do clinicians have a duty to disclose genetic information to offspring?

7 June 2017
Anyone working in healthcare is aware of the legal and ethical quandaries of patient confidentiality and ‘when should I breach confidentiality?’ ABC v (1) St George’s Healthcare NHS Trust (2) South West London and St George’s Mental Health NHS Trust (3) Sussex Partnership NHS Foundation Trust may lead to significant changes to confidentiality duties.

In 2015, a judge struck out a claim that clinicians owed a duty of care to the daughter of a patient diagnosed with Huntington’s Disease on the basis that the claim lacked merit. In 2017, on appeal, the court determined that the daughter’s claims were not unarguable and that more detailed consideration was required.

The tragic facts are that the claimant’s father, convicted for the manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility of her mother, was diagnosed with Huntington’s Disease around the same time that she became pregnant. The clinicians chose to maintain confidentiality and the claimant was subsequently diagnosed with the disease. She argued that had she known this she would have terminated the pregnancy rather than risk passing it on and leaving a child dependent on an ill single parent.

The judgment makes for interesting reading and whilst this case does not change the law, it does demonstrate that the court is willing to tackle the thorny issue of confidentiality vs a competing overriding interest. It will be interesting to see what extent the court balances the legitimate concerns of clinicians regarding floodgates, practical limitations and the potential for undermining patient confidence in the doctor-patient relationship. Watch this space…

The General Medical Council (GMC) has recently revised its guidance on confidentiality and if you would like to discuss this, or the potential implications of this case, please get in touch.

related opinions

Election outcome - Conservative NHS plans?

The NHS was one of the most prominent aspects of the election campaigns and, on the basis of the Tory manifesto, we can now plan.

View blog

Maternity matters - learning lessons from early notification

NHS Resolution has released a report on the first year of the innovative Early Notification (EN) Scheme. The Early Notification scheme progress report: collaboration and improved experience for families draws together key themes and recommendations from an analysis of cases from the first year of the scheme (2017/2018).

View blog

The future of NHS patient safety investigations – consultation closes 12 June 2018

The way in which the NHS investigates when things go wrong in order to identify learning and prevent future harm is very much in the spotlight with a number of high profile reports and reviews identifying significant weaknesses in the current system.

View blog

NHS Resolution publishes 'five years of cerebral palsy claims'

In line with its greater strategic focus on prevention and learning to improve safety, NHS Resolution has today published ‘Five years of cerebral palsy claims’.

View blog

mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up