0370 270 6000

Charlie Gard – European Court of Human Rights to hear case

9 June 2017

It would be hard to find a more tragic set of circumstances than Charlie Gard’s case and the understandable anguish for his parents. On Thursday 8 June the Supreme Court took a difficult decision to reject the appeal to allow Charlie to undergo an experimental therapy in the US. He has been on life support at Great Ormond Street Hospital since October 2016 and suffers from a rare condition called mitochondrial depletion syndrome.

The legal argument forwarded by Charlie’s parents was that parents should be allowed to make the decision unless there was a risk of ‘significant harm,’ and that to do otherwise was a ‘state intrusion on a massive scale’. The hospital’s evidence has been that due to Charlie’s deterioration, therapy would be futile and palliative care was now the only appropriate option. The court determined that whilst "Any court will have the utmost sympathy for parent exploring every possible way of preserving the life of their baby son," they were bound by the factual findings of medical evidence, the welfare of the child was paramount and that the hospital should be allowed to withdraw life support at 17:00 hrs today. This, however, has just changed as the European Court of Human Rights has agreed to look at the case and directed that treatment should continue until Tuesday.

These are inevitably difficult cases for families and medical staff alike. It is not a situation anyone would ever wish to become involved in, but questions of medical futility are becoming more common as advances in medical science are made. What is clear is that these situations always require careful and sensitive consideration. 

Related opinions

The impact of COVID-19 on maternal deaths

HSIB published its report on Maternal deaths during the first wave of COVID-19. The report takes a closer look at the impact that COVID-19 had during the initial period of March to May 2020.

View blog

LPS - it’s out

The long-awaited draft Mental Capacity Act Code of Practice, including the Liberty Protection Safeguards (“LPS”), has landed.

View blog

Decision making and consent

The GMC updated guidance on 'Decision making and consent' comes into effect today, on 9 November 2020, replacing the previous guidance.

View blog

The impact of coronavirus on the management of complaints and serious incident investigations in the NHS

Given the significant challenges and resource implications of the coronavirus on all NHS staff, how should Trusts manage and respond to complaints and Serious Incident Investigations? Do the relevant time limits still apply?

View blog

Mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up