already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

National Audit Office reports on outsourcing public services

14 November 2013

The National Audit Office's recent report on contracting with the private sector raises several questions about how outsourcing contracts operate.

In comparing the profitability of public sector contracts with their other activities the NAO concluded the average return made by large outsourcing firms on government contracts is lower than on private sector deals so its difficult to read from this that the public sector is getting a bad deal, but profit margins do vary between contracts.

However the NAO is concerned provisions such as "open-book" accounting, benchmarking and profit-sharing arrangements are used inconsistently across public sector deals.

Given outsourcing of public services is controversial to many, including mechanisms to ensure this type of transparency may be to everyone’s advantage. As the NAO warns, political pressure merely to reduce costs could cause providers to exit certain public sector markets, stifle innovation, reduce competition and possibly lead to higher prices.

The points raised by the NAO underline the importance of embedding transparency and a partnership ethos in outsourced contracts.

related opinions

NHS Trust to face corporate manslaughter charge

The Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007 was enacted against a background of failed manslaughter prosecutions in particular of large private sector organisations.

View blog

Mostyn maligned as Cheshire West anniversary approaches

Mr Justice Mostyn’s decision in Rochdale MBC v KW and others – that someone not physically or mentally able to leave was not deprived of their liberty – surprised many.

View blog

Care cap consultation

The Government is consulting on draft regulations and guidance on the cap on care costs due to be introduced on 1 April 2016, and the appeals system to consider whether the cap has been reached.

View blog

Firms flouting minimum wage named and shamed

The government has named a further 70 employers who have failed to pay their workers the National Minimum Wage (NMW), bringing the total named since October 2013 to 162.

View blog