logo-education
0370 270 6000

already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

Abdulla decision revives old equal pay claims

17 November 2011
In the past few years, schools across the country have had to deal with equal pay claims arising out of single status. Whether it is defending these claims, negotiating settlement, or having a reduction in delegated budget due to councils’ decisions to settle group claims, few schools have been untouched. Until now, employees have always pursued equal pay claims in employment tribunals. The time limit for presenting an equal pay claim to an employment tribunal is, in the majority of cases, six months from the end of employment. The recent case of Abdulla v Birmingham City Council, has implications which may mean that a whole raft of claims which previously were though to be out of time, may now be able to be pursued. 
 

The Abdulla case 

In this case 174 former employees consider that they have claims in respect of bonuses paid to predominantly male groups in jobs the employees say were rated as equivalent by the employer in accordance with a job evaluation scheme in the Blue Book (collectively agreed terms and conditions for manual workers in local authorities). They were all too late to bring a claim in the employment tribunals, so issued breach of contract claims in the High Court where the time limit for bringing a claim is six years from the date of the breach. The council applied to strike out the claims, inviting the court to exercise its discretion under s. 2(3) Equal Pay Act 1970, which provides that where it appears to the court that the claim “… could more conveniently be disposed of separately by an employment tribunal, the court may direct that the claim… be struck out…” 

The decision 

Dismissing the Council’s application, Colin Edelman QC held that the employees could bring their claims in the High Court. He considered that 'disposed of' meant determining the merits of a particular case and so it could not be 'more convenient' for a claim to be disposed of by an employment tribunal, in circumstances where the tribunal would simply strike it out for being out of time. The decision here is in direct contrast to a similar case involving the same employer in which another judge held that the claim should be struck out for this reason. 

Potential implications for employers 

Subject to the outcome of any appeal, it will now be possible for employees to bring equal pay claims in the High Court within six years of their final pay date. It may also mean that an employee who had previously brought an equal pay claim in the employment tribunal, but had it struck out as being out of time, can now bring their claim in the High Court. In terms of the amount of any claim, back-pay can only be claimed for six years from the date the claim is issued at court, so the amount of compensation ought, theoretically, to be the same as if the claim were brought in the employment tribunals. If High Court equal pay claims are lost or settled by the employer, they will certainly be more expensive than if they had been brought in the employment tribunals. This is because, in High Court litigation, the losing side generally has to pay the winner’s legal fees. If the employee’s solicitors are acting on a ‘no-win-no-fee’ basis, then the losing side’s liability can also include a ‘success fee’ of up to 100% of normal charges, and the premiums for 'after the event' legal expenses insurance. However, the prospect of having to pay the employer’s legal costs may act as a barrier to employees bringing claims with little prospect of success. As a practical point, if you receive a High Court or County Court claim form, you should seek legal advice without delay as action is normally required within 14 days to protect your position.

training and events

8Jun

PraxisAuril 2021 Conference Online

Come and meet our Head of Higher Education, Bettina Rigg and colleagues who will be online throughout this four day conference to discuss how our full service team can support your institution. Please note that this event was postponed from June 2020.

View event

focus on...

Legal updates

Back to School: HR and employment FAQs, March 2021

Despite the national vaccination rollout going to plan it is understandable that many school staff will be feeling hesitant about next week’s almost full return to the school site. We have put together FAQs to assist with your ongoing support and management of your employees.

View

Legal updates

be connected newsletter for education - March 2021

In this edition we provide you with the latest in legal updates, news and insight from the sector.

View

Rising to the challenge: Digital transformation in schools - Part 2

Catch up for part 2 of our education training videos, exploring the role of digital transformation on our education system.

View

Legal updates

Removing employees as members from 1 March 2021

As of 1 March 2021, the Academies Financial Handbook 2020 requires that no employee of an academy trust is a member of that academy trust.

View

The content on this page is provided for the purposes of general interest and information. It contains only brief summaries of aspects of the subject matter and does not provide comprehensive statements of the law. It does not constitute legal advice and does not provide a substitute for it.

mailing list sign up



Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up