logo-education
0370 270 6000

already registered?

Please sign in with your existing account details.

need to register?

Register to access exclusive content, sign up to receive our updates and personalise your experience on brownejacobson.com.

Privacy statement - Terms and conditions

Forgotten your password?

Should redundancy be a tick box exercise?

14 August 2012

When making redundancies from a pool of staff, the safest approach is always to use objective criteria that can be measured, reducing the risk of challenge. Or is it? The employment appeal tribunal (EAT) has cautioned against this approach in a recent decision.

The employment tribunal criticised the employer for using subjective selection criteria, one of which was: ‘which of 5 management roles could be lost with the least effect on the organisation.’ On appeal, the EAT said there was nothing wrong with using subjective criteria. It went on to caution against only using criteria which can be 'scored or assessed' as that could reduce selection procedures to box ticking exercises. Just because subjective criteria are matters of judgement, it does not mean that they cannot be assessed in a dispassionate or objective way. Hopefully this decision will give employers more confidence in using a selection process which is both fair and best suited to the needs of the organisation.

Related opinions

Head of Education, Mark Blois celebrates 25 years of being an education lawyer

Mark Blois, Browne Jacobson’s national Head of Education, is marking a notable anniversary, an incredible 25 years as an education lawyer.

View blog

Be wary of events post-dating the presentation of an Employment Tribunal claim

In Sakyi-Opare v Albert Kennedy Trust, the EAT held that an Employment Tribunal erred in deciding a claim was out of time because it did not first consider the claimant’s application to amend her claim, which included events that post-dated her claim.

View blog

A level results: what this means for schools and higher education?

This year’s A Level results have been a resounding success and demonstrate the commitment and resilience of students, schools and school staff during these unprecedented times. However, there will inevitably be some students who are disappointed with the teacher assessed grade.

View blog

Does the move into Step 4 mean the ending of Covid-19 restrictions within schools?

With the Prime Ministers announcement that he intends for Step 4 to begin on 19 July, this will also bring an end to the restrictions currently in place on education settings.

View blog

Mailing list sign up

Select which mailings you would like to receive from us.

Sign up